Providence’s effort to transform Public Street into a pedestrian‑friendly waterfront park has hit a legal hurdle. According to ecoRI News, Sims Metal Management, a neighboring scrap‑metal facility, filed a formal objection to the city’s permit application that seeks to repave the street, add landscaping, green infrastructure and a boardwalk along the Providence River.
The dispute matters to residents because the project, first designated a public right‑of‑way by the Coastal Resources Management Council (CRMC) in 2021, promises safer pedestrian access, storm‑water treatment and new public space. If the objection proceeds to a council vote, the timeline for construction could be extended.
In a public meeting on Nov. 8, People’s Port Authority executive director Monica Huertas explained that the city’s plan would reallocate portions of the right‑of‑way to create a “people’s street” at the water’s edge. She noted that a hearing on the objection is scheduled for early December.
Sims Metal’s objection, submitted on behalf of the company by Joelle Rocha, argues that its waterfront operations rely on unrestricted access for industrial trucks and that the proposed limits of disturbance around a deck foundation, biofiltration system and grading could encroach on its property, affect surface and groundwater, and disrupt ongoing environmental remediation. The company also claims the city is abandoning a public right‑of‑way without the legally required process or compensation.
The city countered that it has already submitted a remedial‑action work plan to the Department of Environmental Management (DEM) as part of its CRMC application, which would protect the site’s environmental integrity. Officials said the city adjusted the disturbance boundary to align with the property line, removed work that would occur on Sims Metal’s land, and will keep vehicle entrances open for all abutting properties.
City engineers from Fuss & O’Neill noted that earlier discussions with Sims Metal’s general manager indicated openness to installing a vegetated buffer along the northern property line of one of the company’s lots, a measure that would screen industrial operations from view along the public right‑of‑way.
Earlier objections from Rhode Island Energy, which raised concerns about easement rights and the ability to inspect and maintain remedial features, were withdrawn after the city addressed the utility’s issues, according to city records.
In addition to the waterfront project, Huertas has raised industrial traffic on Public Street with City Council member Pedro Espinal. Espinal introduced an ordinance to limit truck weight on the street to seven tons, but the measure was referred to the Public Works Committee in June and has stalled, according to Washington Park Neighborhood Association president Linda Perri.
What’s next: The city will present its response to Sims Metal’s objection at the early‑December hearing. If the council votes on the matter, the decision could affect the schedule for the pedestrian improvements, drainage upgrades and boardwalk construction that residents anticipate.
Sources: ecori.org