A federal jury on Nov. 20 ruled that the city of Sandy, Oregon, and three of its top officials illegally retaliated against former interim Police Chief Sean Lundry for exercising his First Amendment rights. The verdict awards Lundry a total of $935,000 in damages.
Verdict details
The jury found the city, City Manager Tyler Deems, Deputy City Manager Jeff Aprati and former Mayor Stan Pulliam each liable for retaliation. Lundry receives $850,000 in economic damages and $85,000 in punitive damages—$25,000 against Deems, $10,000 against Aprati and $50,000 against Pulliam. No non‑economic damages were awarded.
The jury did not side with Lundry on two separate due‑process claims nor on his state whistle‑blower retaliation claim. A question regarding wrongful discharge was left unanswered.
Background of the dispute
Lundry joined the Sandy Police Department in 2015 and was serving as interim chief when he applied for the permanent position. In January 2024 the city announced it had selected another candidate, Gary Jensen, pending a background check. Lundry publicly questioned the hiring process, encouraging residents to request public records and to raise concerns with city leaders.
After Lundry posted a critical comment on Facebook—stating he would never accept the chief’s job “with the current mayor, council, and appointed leadership”—the city placed him on paid administrative leave on Feb. 23, 2024. The leave followed an anonymous comment card alleging Lundry had destroyed public records during a criminal investigation. Oregon State Police investigated and found no evidence of wrongdoing.
City officials later disclosed that a $30,000 budget line from the police department had been used to pay a consultant for the chief search, a decision Lundry also challenged. The city disputed any impropriety.
Legal arguments and trial
Lundry’s attorneys, Chris Heywood and Colin Hunter, argued that his criticism and record‑request efforts were protected speech. The city contended that Lundry’s termination was based on legitimate personnel concerns, including alleged workplace misconduct and a secret recording of a conversation with Deems.
During the trial, both sides agreed that the city learned of the recording only after Lundry’s termination, during discovery.
Reactions
“This was always a free speech case to us, and we presented it that way,” said Heywood. He called the verdict a “terrific outcome” and a vindication for Lundry, noting that while the jury did not award due‑process relief, the retaliation finding sends a clear message about protecting public‑employee speech.
Police Lieutenant Sam Craven said any city response would be posted on the department’s website and social media, but did not anticipate a comment at this time. KPTV reached out to the city for comment and has not received a response.
Implications for Sandy
The verdict underscores the importance of transparency in municipal hiring processes and reinforces legal protections for public employees who speak out on matters of public concern. City officials may need to review internal policies to ensure future actions are firmly grounded in legitimate, non‑retaliatory reasons.
Original reporting: KPTV FOX 12 Portland (news) — read the source article.