When planning for retirement, the amount of savings required depends heavily on where you plan to live. SmartAsset used a 4.7% initial withdrawal rate to estimate the savings needed for essential and discretionary expenses in 55 of the nation’s largest counties. The study, released in November 2026, provides a clear picture of how housing costs, local prices and Social Security benefits shape retirement budgets.
Most Expensive County for Renters
Among the counties examined, Kings County, New York – which includes Brooklyn – tops the list for single renters. After accounting for average Social Security benefits, a renter would need an estimated $736,897 in savings to cover both essential and typical discretionary spending. Homeowners without a mortgage in the same county would require about $389,408.
Impact of Losing Social Security
If Social Security were eliminated, the savings gap widens dramatically. A single renter in Santa Clara County, California would need roughly $1.3 million to meet essential and discretionary costs. By contrast, Kanawha County, West Virginia – one of the most affordable areas studied – would require about $722,073 under the same conditions.
Most Affordable County for Mortgage‑Free Homeowners
Wake County, North Carolina, emerges as the most affordable location for a mortgage‑free homeowner receiving average Social Security benefits. The analysis estimates that a single homeowner would need only $59,908 in retirement savings to cover essential and discretionary expenses.
Can Social Security Alone Sustain a Retirement?
In 16 of the 55 counties, a mortgage‑free homeowner receiving average Social Security benefits could theoretically cover essential expenses without any additional retirement savings. This scenario assumes no discretionary spending and relies solely on the Social Security benefit.
Guidance on the 4% Rule
Retirement planners often cite the 4% rule as a starting point, but the SmartAsset study uses a slightly higher 4.7% withdrawal rate based on later research by William Bengen. The rule provides an initial estimate; retirees should expect spending patterns to evolve and may need a more flexible approach.
Options for Those Facing a Savings Shortfall
Retirees whose essential expenses exceed their Social Security and investment income may consider part‑time work or rely on family support. Low‑income seniors can also reduce costs through programs such as SNAP, Meals on Wheels, the Housing Choice Voucher Program, Low Income Home Energy Assistance, and subsidized public transit. Availability varies by locality, and some programs have waiting lists.
Methodology Snapshot
Essential spending figures were drawn from the University of Massachusetts Boston’s Elder Index, covering housing, healthcare, transportation, food and other basics for single adults in good health. Discretionary spending was estimated at $6,257 annually, based on the 2024 Consumer Expenditure Survey for seniors, then adjusted for inflation through December 2025 and regional price differences. Savings needs were calculated by subtracting average Social Security income from modeled expenses and dividing the remainder by a 4.7% withdrawal rate. The study covers 55 of the nation’s largest counties and is not representative of smaller or rural areas.
Takeaway for Prospective Retirees
Understanding local cost differences is crucial when setting retirement savings goals. Whether you plan to stay in a high‑cost urban county or relocate to a more affordable region, tailoring your savings strategy to the specific expenses of your chosen area can help ensure a financially secure retirement.
Original reporting: KTVZ (Central Oregon) — read the source article.