It’s 11:47 on a Tuesday morning and the parking lot at Kroll’s West on Ridge Road is already half full. Not because anything special is happening. Just because it’s Kroll’s, and in Green Bay, that’s reason enough.
Kroll’s West has been doing its thing on the west side since 1936. The building looks like it’s been there since before the concept of renovation occurred to anyone, which is not a complaint. The booths are worn in the right places. The menu is laminated and unchanged in spirit if not in print. You could bring your grandmother here and she would recognize everything on the table, including the butter pat situation.
The fish fry runs year-round, not just on Fridays, though Friday is when the place earns its reputation. They serve lake perch and cod, beer-battered and fried in the Wisconsin tradition — meaning properly fried, not apologetically fried. The perch is the move if you’ve got the appetite for it. It comes in a basket with rye bread, coleslaw, and tartar sauce that doesn’t taste like it came out of a squeeze bottle from a warehouse somewhere in New Jersey. Prices are honest: around $14–$17 depending on what you order, and the portions will not leave you wondering where your money went.
What makes Kroll’s West different from the fish fry at every other bar and grill in a fifty-mile radius is harder to articulate but easy to feel. It’s not trying to be anything. There’s no concept here, no locally-sourced pitch, no cocktail menu with a paragraph explaining the provenance of the bitters. The bartender knows the regulars by order. The woman who’s been waitressing here since your parents were in high school will not ask you how everything is tasting. She’ll just check if you need more tartar sauce, which you do.
The butter burgers are worth mentioning even though we’re supposed to be talking about the fish fry, because ignoring the butter burger at Kroll’s West would be like visiting Lambeau and not looking at the field. The meat is ground fresh, the bun gets buttered before it hits the grill, and the whole thing is small enough that ordering two makes complete sense. The guilt is minimal. The satisfaction is not.
On a weekday, the lunch crowd peaks around noon and clears by 1:15. Friday evenings are a different situation entirely — expect a wait, budget for it, don’t be irritated by it. The wait is part of the texture of the place. Bring someone you can talk to.
Kroll’s West is on the 1900 block of South Ridge Road, easy to reach from most of the west side, with ample parking. Hours run roughly 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. most days, though calling ahead on holidays is advisable. Cash is welcome, cards are accepted, and tipping well is culturally mandatory in a place like this.
Green Bay has no shortage of fish fries. It has very few places that make you feel like the week is going to be okay just because you walked in the door. That’s the thing about Kroll’s West that doesn’t show up in any review. You notice it on a rainy Tuesday, when the parking lot is already half full and nobody seems to be in a hurry to leave.