The Ohio State Buckeyes entered the 2026 college football season with high expectations after an undefeated 2025 regular season and a narrow loss to Indiana in the Big Ten Championship. Early in the year the team appeared poised to contend for a national title, but a series of close defeats has left fans and analysts questioning the path forward.
Recent on‑field performance
After a promising start, the Buckeyes fell 24‑23 to Texas despite holding a 23‑3 lead late in the fourth quarter. The loss was followed by a convincing win over Illinois and a solid road victory against Iowa. However, the momentum shifted dramatically on October 17 when starting quarterback Julian Sayin suffered a season‑ending arm injury during the win over Indiana.
Coach Ryan Day turned to backup quarterback Luke Fahey for the next game against USC. The Trojans defeated Ohio State 30‑18, with the Buckeyes’ defense struggling to contain USC’s quarterback Jayden Maiava and a rash of penalties compounding the loss. The following week the Buckeyes faced Oregon in Columbus, jumping to a 14‑0 lead before surrendering 38 unanswered points and losing 41‑28.
Jeremiah Smith’s situation
Jeremiah Smith, who holds the school’s career touchdown and reception records and helped secure a national championship, has become the focal point of the debate. Former NFL running back Damien Harris, speaking on CBS Sports, asserted that Smith’s season may be over, stating, “We just watched Jeremiah Smith play his last snap at Ohio State. He’s done. He’s going to pack it up.” Harris argued that Smith has little left to gain by remaining on the field, especially with the Buckeyes’ playoff hopes fading.
Local radio host Jeremy Birmingham of 97.1 The Fan criticized Smith’s on‑field demeanor, calling him a “petulant child” after the player showed visible frustration following a modest gain late in the third quarter. Birmingham emphasized that a team captain should model composure, not anger.
Smith has not publicly confirmed any decision to sit out. He recently posted a statement defending his effort and expressing a continued desire to compete, suggesting that he still believes the team can contend for the Big Ten title and a potential College Football Playoff berth.
What’s at stake?
If Smith chooses to sit out, the Buckeyes would lose a premier offensive weapon for the remainder of the season. The decision could also affect his Heisman candidacy and NFL draft stock, as scouts often weigh durability and commitment alongside talent. Conversely, remaining active carries the risk of injury that could jeopardize his professional prospects.
The Buckeyes still have two regular‑season games against Northwestern and Nebraska before the traditional rivalry matchup against Michigan. Those contests present an opportunity for the team to rebound and secure a spot in the Big Ten Championship Game, which would keep a playoff path alive.
Community perspective
Ohio State supporters, many of whom are families and faith‑based groups, are divided. Some argue that Smith should stay the course, honoring his leadership role and the team’s collective effort. Others echo Harris and Birmingham, suggesting that stepping aside could preserve Smith’s legacy and allow the Buckeyes to develop younger talent.
Regardless of the outcome, the discussion underscores the importance of perseverance, accountability, and the role of strong family and community values in collegiate athletics.
Looking ahead
The next few weeks will determine whether Jeremiah Smith returns to the field or opts for a season‑long hiatus. Ohio State fans will be watching closely, hoping the team can rally around its remaining leaders and finish the season with pride.
Original reporting: Fox News (HLL/CB) — read the source article.
