Scottsdale residents may soon see a new dining destination at 3831 N. Scottsdale Road, the former home of the iconic Pink Pony Steak House. The building, listed as a Scottsdale historic landmark, was originally constructed in 1954 by the Sprouse‑Reitz variety store and later modified in 1970 to house the Pink Pony after the restaurant moved from its downtown location, according to the Scottsdale Historic Register.
Owned for many years by Charlie Briley, the Pink Pony became a celebrated gathering spot for spring‑training baseball teams. The venue’s interior featured a “virtual shrine to baseball” with signed memorabilia, photographs and caricature drawings of players such as Ty Cobb, Ted Williams, Rogers Hornsby, Jimmy Foxx, Joe DiMaggio and Billy Martin, as noted in the historic register.
The property has remained empty for over a decade after an “ill‑fated attempt” to revive it roughly 15 years ago disturbed much of the historic interior and failed quickly, according to a November 5 letter from the law firm Withey Morris Baugh. The letter announced that an internationally renowned food purveyor has now purchased the site and engaged acclaimed architect Wendell Burnette to reimagine the space.
The proposed vision calls for three high‑end restaurant concepts plus a fourth concept that would pay homage to the baseball‑themed Pink Pony, preserving the spirit and story of the former “watering hole.” The plan would replace the single‑restaurant layout with a “collection of distinctive restaurants capable of reviving the Pink Pony’s iconic history,” the letter states.
To move forward, the developers must obtain City Council approval to remove the historic property designation, which the letter argues is no longer applicable given the building’s extensive alterations and degradation. Withey Morris Baugh is hosting an open house to discuss the proposal at 5 p.m. on Monday, Nov. 16, at the property itself.
Scottsdale officials have not yet commented on the proposal, and the council’s decision on the historic designation removal will determine whether the new restaurant concepts can proceed.
What’s next: Interested residents can attend the open house on Nov. 16 to learn more about the project and provide input before the City Council considers the historic designation request at a future meeting.
Sources: scottsdale.org