The City of New Haven announced a plan to remove 24 maple trees on Wooster Street that have been deemed unsafe or beyond treatment. The decision follows a routine arborist inspection that identified the trees as suffering from structural defects, invasive species, and disease that cannot be remedied.
City explains the need for action
Tree Warden Annie Mixsell told the New Haven Independent that many of the maples lining Wooster Street show signs of stress, damage, and disease caused by urban stress factors, heavy pruning for utility wires, and recent sidewalk and roadway upgrades that injured root systems. “We are focused on creating a resilient urban tree canopy and expediting the replacement of removed trees so neighborhoods do not suffer the loss of benefits like shade and beauty,” Mixsell said.
According to the Parks Department, the 24 trees slated for removal were identified during the inspection, which also noted four trees had previously been posted for removal. An additional 26 trees on the same block were classified as suitable for preservation measures such as pruning and plant health care techniques.
Public hearing to address community concerns
The city will hold a public hearing at 5:30 p.m. on Monday, Nov. 30, in Room G‑2 at 200 Orange Street. Residents are encouraged to attend to learn how trees are inspected, how risk factors are identified, and how they can help adopt and steward the next generation of resilient street trees.
Mixsell indicated that a phased approach to removal and replacement is possible for some of the trees, and that the preservation‑eligible trees will be treated with professional pruning and care.
Neighbors voice opposition
Local residents Diane Scaglione and Sarah Ficca expressed concern over the scale of the removals, noting that removal notices had appeared on as many as 20 trees and that many notices have since been taken down, making the exact count unclear. “To raze all the trees would be a pretty unsightly street,” Scaglione said.
Ficca questioned the timing, asking why the city chose to remove so many trees at once rather than spreading the work over time. Both neighbors urged the city to reconsider the plan and seek an independent arborist evaluation.
Petition calls for transparency
Scaglione and another neighbor launched a Change.org petition that has gathered 282 signatures. The petition asks the city to provide a clear, tree‑by‑tree explanation for each removal and to explore alternatives such as treatment, pruning, or other maintenance measures that could preserve the trees without compromising public safety.
Wooster Square Alder Mandy Martinelli praised the community’s call for transparency, noting that the petition had already attracted more than 260 signatures. She affirmed that the city will hold the Nov. 30 hearing to give residents an opportunity to be heard before any irreversible decisions are made.
What’s next?
City officials will review public comments at the hearing and determine which trees will be removed, replaced or preserved. The Parks Department emphasizes that the overall goal is to maintain a healthy, safe, and beautiful streetscape for New Haven’s historic Wooster Street while protecting residents from potential hazards.
Original reporting: New Haven Independent — read the source article.