New Haven officials filed a lawsuit in Connecticut federal court on Nov. 13, accusing Westport Insurance Corporation of failing to honor insurance coverage for the city’s $30.5 million wrongful‑conviction settlements with Marquis Jackson and Vernon Horn, according to the New Haven Independent.
The city’s lawsuit contends that Westport, which succeeded Coregis Insurance Company, should pay beyond the $5 million it agreed to under a 1998 policy. New Haven argues that policies issued between 1999 and 2003—Public Entity Excess Law Enforcement Liability Coverage and Public Entity General Liability Coverage—cover “bodily injury” and “personal injury” claims arising from wrongful arrest, detention, malicious prosecution, and civil‑rights violations. Both Jackson and Horn claim they suffered those injuries during their nearly two‑decade incarcerations.
Mayor Justin Elicker announced in August that the city settled the two wrongful‑conviction lawsuits for $15.25 million each, totaling $30.5 million. He said the 1998 insurance policy would pay $5 million plus attorney’s fees, leaving the city responsible for the remaining $25.5 million. In October, city aldermen approved a $27 million borrowing plan to cover the city’s share of the settlements.
City Corporation Counsel Allison Jacobs told the Independent that the administration seeks “appropriate reimbursement based on the insurance coverage it had at the time.” She noted that Westport has agreed to defend and indemnify the city only under the 1998 policy, not under the later policies that were in effect when the wrongful incarcerations occurred.
The lawsuit seeks monetary damages, pre‑judgment and post‑judgment interest, costs, and other relief. Westport could not be reached for comment at the time of reporting.
This legal action follows recent high‑profile wrongful‑conviction cases in Connecticut, including a $16.5 million settlement with Adam Carmon and a $38 million jury award to Stefon Morant, which the city is currently appealing.
Sources: newhavenindependent.org