Ozark, Mo. – State education leaders gathered Thursday to weigh in on Missouri’s newly proposed A‑F grading system for public and charter schools. The forum, hosted by the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE), gave superintendents a chance to ask hard questions before the framework moves to the State Board of Education.
Key concerns from district leaders
Dr. Mark Drake, superintendent of Monett Schools, opened the discussion by emphasizing the need for clarity before rollout. “Anytime you’re rolling out a new initiative, you need to make sure that you’re answering most questions before you roll that out,” he said, then asked whether DESE could advocate on districts’ behalf before the board if the system proved unready.
Zac Rantz, chief communication officer for Nixa Schools, warned that reducing student achievement to a single letter grade ignores the many ways schools measure success. “We’re really concerned that we’re reducing everything about our kids to a letter grade when there are so many other things that measure how successful they are,” he explained.
Dr. David Schmitz, superintendent of Lebanon Schools, echoed the sentiment, noting that the grading model leaves out vital aspects of school life. “The work we do to help kids explore, discover and pursue their passions and interests, the things we do to take care of kids, there’s so much to celebrate, and I think that the narrow focus of data that informs that letter grade leaves out so much in the story,” he said.
Resource gaps and equity worries
Several participants highlighted how the framework might overlook resource disparities. Greg Kester of the Missouri National Education Association argued that districts with high percentages of students receiving free and reduced lunch need extra support. “After teaching 30 years in a classroom in an impoverished school district where we have 100 percent free and reduced lunch, those districts need support more than anything,” he said.
Drake added that measuring performance only at the whole‑district level could mask the challenges faced by English‑language learner (ELL) populations, students with individualized education programs (IEPs), and high‑mobility schools. “You talk about free and reduced lunch populations or high‑poverty areas and we talk about ELL schools… all of those things cannot be captured in this system,” he noted.
How the grading system is designed
The A‑F framework stems from Governor Mike Kehoe’s January executive order. It proposes an annual letter grade based primarily on test scores and student growth. For high schools, graduation rates and college‑and‑career readiness metrics would also factor into the final rating.
Under the tentative timeline, districts will receive draft grades using data from the 2025‑26 school year before the results are made public in December. The final proposal is slated for presentation to the State Board of Education on Dec. 15.
Looking ahead
While the meeting highlighted significant concerns, DESE officials indicated they will consider the feedback as they refine the model. The agency plans to release a revised version that better accounts for socioeconomic and linguistic factors, though no specific changes were announced at the Ozark session.
Stakeholders agreed that a transparent, data‑driven approach is essential, but they stressed that any grading system must reflect the full picture of student achievement and school effort, especially in districts facing pronounced resource gaps.
Original reporting: KY3 Springfield (local) — read the source article.