It was a Tuesday around eleven in the morning when I first walked into Mary’s Coins & Collectibles on South Tacoma Way, mostly because my uncle had given me a coffee can full of old silver dollars and I had no idea what to do with them. That was three years ago. I still go back.
Mary Larson has been behind that counter — or close to it — since 1982. She’s in her seventies now, with reading glasses perpetually pushed up on her head and an opinion about every coin you set in front of her. She’ll flip a Morgan dollar over in about two seconds and tell you the mint mark, the grade, and roughly what it sold for at the last major auction. She’s not performing expertise. She just knows.
The shop itself sits in a low strip of retail on South Tacoma Way that has seen better decades. There’s a pawn shop two doors down, a closed nail salon next to that. Mary’s has been here through all of it. Inside, the cases run the full length of the room — glass-topped, well-lit, organized in a way that only makes sense once she explains it to you. One case is nothing but Mercury dimes and Walking Liberty halves. Another holds foreign coins sorted by region. There’s a rotating section of paper currency near the back, and a wall display of old Washington state tokens that stops a lot of people cold.
Prices are fair without being aggressive. I bought a 1921 Peace dollar in decent circulated condition for thirty-eight dollars on my second visit, and I’ve since seen the same coin go for more at shows. She’s not trying to squeeze you. She’ll also buy, and she pays in cash on the spot — no appointment, no appraisal fee, no waiting three days for a callback. If you bring in something she can’t use, she’ll tell you that too, and sometimes point you toward someone who can.
What keeps drawing me back isn’t really the inventory, though that changes enough to make repeat visits worthwhile. It’s that Mary treats the whole thing like a conversation. She remembers what I’ve bought before. She’ll set something aside if she thinks I’d want it, and she was right the last time she did that — a 1916 Buffalo nickel in a flip with a small handwritten note on the grade. Twenty-two dollars. I didn’t argue.
The shop doesn’t have a flashy website or a heavy social media presence. Walk-in traffic and word of mouth have kept it running for over four decades, which says something. On weekday mornings it’s usually quiet — maybe one or two other collectors browsing the cases, the kind of people who know what they’re looking at. Saturday afternoons bring more foot traffic, including a fair number of people coming in with inherited collections they don’t know how to value. Mary handles those interactions with patience I genuinely admire.
If you’re a serious numismatist, you probably already know about her. If you’re not but you’ve got a coffee can of old coins gathering dust somewhere, this is exactly where to start. Bring the whole can. She won’t mind.