Federal Judge Lance Walker of the U.S. District Court for the District of Maine issued a decision Friday that the Hermon School Committee acted with unlawful religious bias when it refused a lease request from The Pines Church of Bangor. The church’s lead pastor, Matt Gioia, had asked to rent space at Hermon High School for Sunday worship services for a full year, rather than a month‑to‑month arrangement.
Background of the lease request
In 2022, Pastor Gioia contacted the Hermon School Department to discuss the proposed use of school facilities. After presenting his plan, committee member Christopher McLaughlin sent a series of questions through then‑Superintendent Micah Grant. The inquiries focused on the church’s stance on “issues of diversity, equity, and inclusion,” as well as its views on same‑sex marriage, abortion, and transgender matters.
Superintendent Grant forwarded the questions to Pastor Gioia, who later received an apology from Grant for the line of questioning. Nevertheless, Grant and school committee chair Jesse Keith later sought legal advice on whether allowing the church to use the school would constitute an “unlawful establishment of religion” and whether denying the request would breach the First Amendment.
Judge’s findings
Judge Walker concluded that while Grant himself did not display bias, at least three committee members—McLaughlin, Stephanie Oiler, and Karen Shorey—were improperly influenced by the church’s religious identity. He wrote, “It appears that he based his decision directly on the Plaintiffs’ religious beliefs and its associated political and cultural ethics that flow from those beliefs.” Walker determined that the committee’s actions violated both the First Amendment and Maine’s public accommodations law.
Although the judge recognized the committee’s misconduct, he denied the church’s request for an injunction to block future lease denials. Walker noted that the church’s attorneys had not shown that the school’s written rental policy was unconstitutional or that the church would suffer irreparable harm without an injunction.
Reactions from the community
Hermon School Superintendent Barbara Sargent said the department is reviewing the ruling and will consider procedural adjustments. “While this legal matter has concluded, the Hermon School Department’s dedication to its students remains unchanged,” she said. “We remain focused on providing an exceptional educational experience, supporting our professional staff, and maintaining a school environment where student success is the highest priority.”
Advocates for Faith & Freedom, which represented the church, praised the decision as a victory for religious liberty. President Bob Tyler stated, “This ruling affirms a fundamental principle: when public schools open their facilities to community groups such as sports teams, scouts, and recreation programs, they cannot exclude churches simply because of their faith.”
What this means for local schools
The ruling underscores the importance of neutral treatment of religious organizations seeking access to public school facilities. It serves as a reminder to school committees across Maine—and the nation—that decisions must be based on secular criteria, not on the religious beliefs of applicants.
Local officials and parents are watching closely, as the case may influence future requests for community use of school spaces. The Hermon School Department has indicated it will examine its rental policies to ensure compliance with constitutional standards while continuing to serve the educational needs of its students.
Original reporting: Fox News (HLL/CB) — read the source article.