Liverpool, N.Y. – At a recent Board of Education meeting, Liverpool School District Board member Matt Jones publicly challenged the legal guidance that led to a new directive eliminating confidentiality between school staff and students on matters of pregnancy, sexuality and religion. The policy, adopted on Monday, prompted a student‑organized walkout at Liverpool High School on Friday morning.
Board member’s concerns
In a statement released on his own behalf, Jones said he was speaking solely as an individual Board member, not on behalf of the entire Board. He expressed deep concern that the directive “significantly erodes trust between our students and the adults entrusted with their care” and places teachers, counselors and administrators in an “untenable position.”
Jones praised Superintendent Richard Chapman for his dedication to students and staff, noting that the superintendent was “placed in an extraordinarily difficult position by the legal guidance he received.” However, Jones emphasized that his frustration is directed at the advice that produced the directive, not at the superintendent himself.
Call for independent legal opinion
Given the serious implications for the school community, Jones formally requested that the Board seek an independent second legal opinion on the advice that led to the memorandum. He clarified that he had no involvement in drafting or approving the memo and that it was never presented to the Board for approval.
“I am angered that the legal guidance that led to this directive has called our commitment to a safe, welcoming and nurturing environment into question,” Jones wrote. “I am committed to working alongside our superintendent and fellow Board members to repair the damage, rebuild trust, and support our teachers, staff and administrators.”
Superintendent’s response
Following the walkout, Superintendent Chapman issued a statement acknowledging that his earlier explanation of the policy was unclear. He reiterated that a student talking with a teacher or counselor about who they are does not, by itself, trigger a mandatory call home to parents.
Chapman’s clarification aimed to reassure families that the district remains focused on student safety and well‑being while navigating the complex legal landscape surrounding student privacy.
Community reaction
The policy change has generated strong reactions from students, parents and community members who value open communication between students and trusted adults. Many argue that preserving confidentiality is essential for students to feel safe discussing sensitive personal matters.
Jones’ call for an independent legal review reflects a broader desire within the community to ensure that any policy affecting student welfare is grounded in sound legal reasoning and aligns with the district’s longstanding commitment to a supportive educational environment.
Looking ahead
Matt Jones will assume his new role on the Onondaga County Legislature representing the second district on January 1. Until then, he remains active in addressing the confidentiality issue and working toward a resolution that protects both student rights and the responsibilities of school staff.
The Board is expected to schedule a meeting to discuss the request for an independent legal opinion in the coming weeks.
Original reporting: CNY Central WSTM (Sinclair) – local — read the source article.