After months of requests, the Idaho State Tax Commission finally published a breakdown of the parental tax credit program. The report shows that most of the $50 million in voucher money is flowing to families earning well above the state average and to students who have never been enrolled in a public school.
Who is receiving the credit?
The average household that received a voucher this year earned $178,000, more than double the $84,234 average Idaho family income. Seventy‑five percent of the families taking the credit have never sent a child to a public school, contrary to early promises that the program would help students escape “failing” public schools.
Only 4.6 percent of the families who did have a child in a public school were enrolled for a full school year a year ago.
Geographic distribution
Two‑thirds of the voucher money went to families in three counties – Ada, Canyon and Kootenai – highlighting a concentration in urban areas. Rural counties received a much smaller share.
School recipients
Nearly a quarter of the funds were directed to just five private schools, most of which are religious institutions: Bishop Kelly High School (Boise), Cole Valley Christian (Meridian), Nampa Christian School, The Ambrose School (Meridian) and Logos Classical Christian School (Moscow), the latter led by Doug Wilson.
Political response
Sen. Janie Ward‑Engelking, a retired teacher and vocal opponent of the voucher program, called the findings “a pretty lousy deal for rural Idaho” and urged the governor to explain why a well‑off family can receive state help while rural schools struggle to fund teachers.
Governor Brad Little and the Republican legislators who passed the credit have been criticized for ignoring these data. More than 32,000 Idahoans contacted the governor’s office asking for a veto, but the bill was signed into law and the legislators were re‑elected.
National context
Voucher programs have become a partisan flashpoint in recent mid‑term elections. In Texas, Arizona, Iowa and Ohio, voters rejected or limited similar initiatives, while Idaho’s Republican lawmakers retained their seats despite the controversy.
Looking ahead
Critics argue that the program violates the Idaho Constitution’s ban on using taxpayer dollars for religious schools and that the $50 million could be better spent bolstering underfunded public schools, especially in working‑class and rural communities.
Governor Little has pledged greater transparency and accountability, saying the newly released data will help evaluate the program’s effectiveness. Whether the legislature will act on those findings remains to be seen.
Original reporting: Idaho Education News — read the source article.