Handlebars has never been featured on a food magazine cover, and that might be the best thing about it. The place opened in Silverton in 1972 — which makes it older than most of the people eating there on a given Friday night — and it has the institutional confidence that comes with five decades of not really needing your approval.
I first went on a rainy Tuesday in September, the kind of afternoon when Silverton empties out fast and you find yourself wondering if anything is actually open. Handlebars was open. It was also full, in the way that places full of regulars are full: not frantic, just occupied, with the low hum of a room that knows itself.
The building is a converted 1890s brothel — yes, really — on Blair Street, which is Silverton’s other main drag, the one that runs parallel to Greene and historically handled the rougher commerce of a mining town. The exterior still has that heavy-timbered Victorian look, and inside, the walls are layered with antique bicycles, vintage mining equipment, and taxidermy arranged without any apparent design intention. It is a lot to look at. Eventually you stop trying to take it all in and just order a beer.
They brew their own. The house lager is clean and cold and costs around five dollars, which feels almost anachronistic given what pints run elsewhere in the region. I had two and worked through a plate of their green chile cheeseburger, which arrives on a brioche bun with a pile of fries that are genuinely good — crisp all the way through, not soggy at the bottom. The green chile has real heat to it, the kind that arrives slowly and sticks around.
The menu is longer than you’d expect: ribs, steaks, trout, nachos, elk medallions when they have them. Nothing is precious. Prices stay reasonable for a tourist-adjacent town — most entrees run between sixteen and thirty dollars — and portions are sized for people who have been outside all day, which in Silverton is usually everyone.
Service is quick in the way that comes from practice, not performance. My server had clearly answered the same questions about the building’s history a few hundred times and answered them cheerfully anyway. When I asked what they were most proud of on the menu, she said the ribs, without hesitating, and suggested I come back for dinner when they aren’t slammed.
Getting there matters. Silverton is 48 miles north of Durango up U.S. 550, through the Million Dollar Highway — one of the more dramatic stretches of pavement in the American Southwest. In summer the drive takes about an hour. In October, with the aspens turned, it takes longer because you keep stopping. In winter, go only if you’re comfortable with mountain driving or willing to let someone else do it; the highway closes periodically when conditions get bad.
Handlebars closes for a chunk of winter and typically reopens in spring. Summer hours run daily for lunch and dinner; shoulder season hours get shorter, so call ahead or check their Facebook page before making the trip.
If you’re planning a day in Silverton — the mining museum, a walk along Greene Street, maybe a hike up toward the old mill ruins — Handlebars is the natural place to end up. It’s been ending up there for over fifty years. That’s not an accident.