Massachusetts retirees and taxpayers will see former Stoughton Police Department deputy chief Robert Devine continue to draw a pension of $56,544 per year, according to filings with the Norfolk County Retirement System. The benefit is scheduled to begin in 2023 and will run for the remainder of Devine’s life.
Background of the case
Devine retired in 2022 after the Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) Commission decertified him last year. The commission cited a “pattern of unprofessional police conduct that may escalate” tied to his alleged relationship with Sandra Birchmore, a 23‑year‑old pregnant woman whose 2021 death was originally ruled a suicide but later became a federal homicide investigation.
Birchmore’s death sparked a broader probe that led to the arrest and conviction of former Stoughton officer Matthew Farwell, who was found guilty of killing a witness and violating a federal law protecting unborn children. Farwell had begun a sexual relationship with Birchmore when she was a 15‑year‑old member of the Stoughton Police Youth Explorers program.
Retirement eligibility under state law
Under Massachusetts law, a former officer who has not been criminally convicted remains eligible for retirement benefits, even if the POST Commission revokes his certification. The Norfolk County Retirement System filing confirms Devine’s entitlement to the annual pension, which is calculated based on his years of service and final salary.
Devine has denied the allegations related to Birchmore, stating during his POST hearing that Birchmore “lied about everything.” He is currently appealing the commission’s decision to decertify him.
Public reaction and oversight concerns
Critics, including local advocacy groups focused on police accountability, argue that allowing a decertified officer to collect a sizable pension sends the wrong message about the consequences of misconduct. They point to the case as evidence that existing retirement statutes need reform to better align benefits with conduct findings.
Supporters of the current system note that the law distinguishes between criminal conviction and administrative discipline. They argue that without a conviction, the statutory protections for pension rights remain intact, preserving due‑process safeguards for public employees.
What’s next?
The POST Commission’s appeal is pending, and the case may prompt legislative review of pension eligibility criteria for law‑enforcement personnel who lose certification but avoid criminal charges. Lawmakers in the Massachusetts General Court have expressed interest in hearing testimony from both oversight officials and retired officers to assess whether reforms are warranted.
For now, the Norfolk County Retirement System will continue to disburse Devine’s pension, and the public will watch closely as the appeal proceeds and as state officials consider potential changes to the retirement framework.
Original reporting: NBC10 Boston — read the source article.