Melody Gissentanner, mother of Brian Gillis, has filed a federal wrongful‑death lawsuit against the City of Jacksonville and Officer Caleb Bumgarner of the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office. The suit claims the officer used excessive force when he shot Gillis on August 13, 2025.
Background of the incident
According to attorneys representing the family, Gillis was experiencing a documented mental‑health crisis and his mother had called police seeking help under Florida’s Baker Act. A Sheriff’s Office Behavior Crisis Response Unit arrived just before 8 a.m., accompanied by a licensed mental‑health clinician.
Police reports state that Gillis fled the scene after the initial response. Officer Bumgarner located him a few blocks away just after 9 a.m. and, according to the lawsuit, ordered Gillis to drop a knife he was holding, threatening to release his K9 to bite him. When Gillis turned with the knife, Bumgarner drew his firearm and shot him in the back. Gillis died on East 25th Street near Buckman Street.
Allegations in the lawsuit
The complaint alleges that Officer Bumgarner acted contrary to his training by repeatedly commanding Gillis to drop the weapon, then using lethal force while Gillis was running and “clearly incapacitated.” It also claims the officer failed to apply his own medical kit to stop the bleeding after the shooting.
Attorney Andy Hale, who handles many police‑involved cases, said, “There was no emergency here at all. The officer’s first response was to threaten a dog bite rather than de‑escalate.” He added that Jacksonville deserves better and that “bad apples need to be weeded out.”
Official response
The Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office said it could not comment on pending litigation. The State Attorney’s Office has not yet released an opinion on whether any crimes were committed.
The lawsuit seeks compensatory and punitive damages, as well as attorneys’ fees. Portions of body‑worn camera footage released by the Sheriff’s Office show the officer firing as Gillis ran and then calling for medical assistance.
Original reporting: Jacksonville Today — read the source article.