Dave Negri will tell you he started at Remington’s the year the Diamondbacks were still just a rumor. That’s not a boast — it’s just how he marks time. He’s the dining room manager, and he’s been walking that same stretch of carpet at the Scottsdale Plaza Resort on North Scottsdale Road for going on thirty years. When a place holds onto someone like that, it usually means something is working.
Remington’s sits inside the Scottsdale Plaza Resort, a low-slung, Spanish-colonial property in the stretch between Old Town and McCormick Ranch that doesn’t scream for attention. The restaurant itself reads formal without being stiff — dark wood, warm light, white tablecloths that actually stay pressed. There are maybe fifteen tables in the main room, a few more near the bar. On a weeknight in January, the crowd skews older and quieter, the kind of people who have a reservation and mean to keep it.
The menu is what Dave calls “classic American steakhouse, done correctly.” That means prime beef, fresh seafood flown in several times a week, and sauces made in-house. The filet mingon is the anchor — eight or twelve ounces, cut to order, and seared with enough crust to give it something to say. The rack of lamb has a following among regulars who’ve been coming since the nineties. If you go once and want something to remember, the tableside Caesar is worth the extra five minutes it takes. Dave often does it himself when he’s not managing the floor, dragging the anchovy paste along the bowl with a fork like he’s done it a thousand times, because he has.
Entrées run $45 to $75 for the steaks. The wine list leans California and French, with a solid Arizona section that Dave helped build over time. He’s direct about what pairs well and won’t steer you toward the expensive bottle just because. That matters in a place that could easily coast on its setting and hotel clientele.
What Dave will talk about if you give him an opening is consistency. Not in an abstract way — he means the specific things. The bread basket arrives warm. The water glass gets refilled without being asked. If you’ve been here before and mentioned a preference, there’s a decent chance it’s in the notes. “People come back because nothing surprises them badly,” he said one night, which is not a romantic line, but it’s an honest one.
The patio overlooks the resort’s fountain and garden. In November through March it’s one of the more pleasant outdoor dining situations in Scottsdale — not flashy, just genuinely comfortable, with enough space between tables that you can have a real conversation. In summer, the indoor room handles everything fine.
Remington’s doesn’t generate the kind of buzz that newer Scottsdale spots chase. It doesn’t need to. Dave has seen a lot of restaurants open and close in thirty years, and he doesn’t say that with any smugness. He just keeps showing up, knowing the regulars’ names, and making sure the lamb is right. That’s the whole story.
Reservations are recommended, especially on weekend evenings. Remington’s is at 7200 N. Scottsdale Road inside the Scottsdale Plaza Resort.