Madison residents learned Thursday that the Dane County District Attorney’s Office will not file criminal charges against Madison Police Officer Kiel Baitinger‑Peterson for the fatal shooting of Corey Ruiz on July 22. District Attorney Ismael Ozanne said his review of the nearly 1,800‑page state investigation found the use of deadly force was reasonable under Wisconsin law, given Ruiz’s resistance and the knife he produced.
According to WMTV, four officers responded to a report of a person checking parked vehicles in the Marquette neighborhood. Officers located Ruiz at the intersection of S. Baldwin and Williamson Streets around 1:35 p.m. and attempted to take him into custody. Ruiz fell from his bicycle, and officers repeatedly ordered him to place his hands behind his back. The report states Ruiz pulled a knife from his right hand, prompting Baitinger‑Peterson to claim he was cut and feared being stabbed.
The Boston Globe noted that a second officer deployed a Taser, but both devices were fired at close range, limiting their effectiveness. An Axon expert cited in the Department of Justice investigation said the taser prongs were too close together to incapacitate Ruiz. After Ruiz fell to the ground, Baitinger‑Peterson fired three shots, striking Ruiz once in the torso and once in the head. Firefighters and EMS attempted resuscitation, but Ruiz died at the hospital.
Ozanne’s decision relied on police reports, squad‑car video, citizen footage, and interview transcripts. He concluded that Wisconsin law permits deadly force when an officer reasonably fears deadly force against themselves or others. “A knife can be used as a dangerous weapon and may pose a grave danger of bodily harm or death,” Ozanne said.
Civil‑rights attorney Ben Crump, representing the Ruiz family, condemned the decision, calling the shooting “unreasonable and unjustified” and saying the video showed officers tasing, kicking, and then executing Ruiz. Ruiz’s mother Elsa Ruiz called the outcome “so wrong” and expressed ongoing grief.
Madison Police Chief John Patterson said the department will conduct an extensive internal review of the use‑of‑force incident. All four officers involved remain on paid administrative leave, and Patterson estimated the review will take several weeks. He emphasized the department’s commitment to maintaining community trust despite the emotional impact of the decision.
Protesters gathered at the intersection on Thursday, leaving bouquets and holding a candlelight vigil after dark. The Wisconsin Professional Police Association praised the DA’s decision as consistent with legal standards, while Governor‑elect David Crowley urged any demonstrations to remain peaceful.
What’s next: The Madison Police Department’s internal review will be completed in the coming weeks, after which the chief will release findings and any recommended policy changes. The officers involved will stay on administrative leave pending the outcome.
Sources: wmtv15news.com, bostonglobe.com, wisn.com