A Dallas County judge’s temporary restraining order (TRO) limiting the Horizon Texas Annual Conference’s use of the historic Highland Park Methodist Church name became effective on Thursday, Nov. 19, after the congregation posted the required $5,000 cash bond. Judge Bridgett Whitmore of the 193rd District Court granted the church’s request on Nov. 18, barring the conference from using any variation of “Highland Park United Methodist Church,” “Highland Park UMC,” “HPUMC,” and similar branding that could confuse the community.
What the Order Requires
The order also prohibits the conference from soliciting or accepting donations under the disputed names, or displaying the contested branding online. Both parties are directed to preserve any records that may be relevant to the case.
Church Response
In an email to members that reached The Dallas Express, Highland Park Methodist Church leaders expressed gratitude for the court’s decision. Council Chair Caroline Nowlin and Pastoral Relations Committee Chair Mark Freeman wrote, “We are grateful to share that the Court has granted Highland Park Methodist Church’s request for a Temporary Restraining Order, protecting our church’s longstanding name and identity.” The message emphasized respect for the neighboring congregation’s right to worship while objecting to any name that could cause confusion.
Background of the Dispute
The Horizon Texas Conference sued the church in August, alleging that revisions to governing documents beginning in 2022 bypassed required United Methodist approval, altered the corporate name, and transferred governance and pastoral authority to local leaders. Highland Park leaders dispute those claims, noting that a vote of 4,775 members on Oct. 25‑26 showed 90.35% support for ending ties with the denomination.
Bishop Rubén Saenz Jr. subsequently appointed Rev. Andy Lewis to lead members who wished to remain United Methodist. That group began holding services at Southern Methodist University’s Prothro Great Hall on Nov. 15, near the original sanctuary at 3300 Mockingbird Lane. Lewis described the TRO as “disappointing” but affirmed his commitment to a United Methodist ministry in the Highland Park community.
Faith Leaders Weigh In
Evangelist Franklin Graham, president of Samaritan’s Purse and the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association, praised the congregation’s decision to leave the United Methodist Church in a Nov. 16 post on X. Graham linked the departure to the denomination’s acceptance of LGBTQ clergy and same‑sex marriage, calling the direction an “unbiblical progressive movement.” He also thanked former President George W. Bush and former First Lady Laura Bush for supporting the congregation’s vote.
Next Steps in the Litigation
The restraining order does not resolve the underlying questions about the 2022 governance changes, the congregations’ ultimate denominational status, or property ownership. The court denied the conference’s jurisdictional plea at this preliminary stage. The order expires at 4 p.m. on Dec. 2 unless extended, and a temporary injunction hearing is set for that day via Zoom. Additional hearings are scheduled for Dec. 7 (motion to dismiss) and Oct. 12, 2027 (non‑jury trial).
Highland Park Methodist Church remains hopeful that the Horizon Texas Conference will choose a path allowing both congregations to move forward peacefully, while the court process continues to determine the final legal standing of the two bodies.
Original reporting: The Dallas Express — read the source article.