Shoppers planning to spend on Black Friday or Cyber Monday should pause before clicking “buy now.” A recent study by the consumer‑research group Groundwork Collaborative reveals that a sizable share of the advertised “deals” on Amazon may not be savings at all.
Study methodology and key findings
Groundwork examined more than 350 products featured on Amazon’s Black Friday and Cyber Monday deal pages in 2024 and 2025. Researchers compared each sale price to the product’s price history for the 30 days preceding the holiday events.
The analysis uncovered three notable patterns:
- Almost 1 in 3 items (about 33%) were listed at the same price or a lower price during the month before the sale.
- Roughly 1 in 10 items (about 10%) were actually priced higher during the advertised sale than they had been previously.
- One highlighted example involved a pair of UGG boots advertised for $179.98 on Cyber Monday that had sold for $98.40 about four weeks earlier – an 83% increase over the earlier price.
Comments from Groundwork Collaborative
Breyon Williams, chief economist at Groundwork Collaborative, acknowledged that the investigation did identify genuine savings among the products reviewed. “There were legitimate deals in our report,” Williams said. “We want to make sure that when retailers market a deal, 100 % of those deals are good for consumers. Shoppers should be able to trust that a deal actually saves them money.”
Williams emphasized that retailers should not settle for a 75 % success rate. “We shouldn’t say, ‘OK, well, 75 % are good,’” he added. “100 % of the deals should save shoppers money.”
Practical steps for shoppers
Groundwork offers several simple actions consumers can take before finalizing a holiday purchase:
- Check the product’s price history using online tools rather than relying solely on the advertised discount.
- Compare prices at other retailers to ensure you’re getting the best offer.
- Focus on the actual dollar amount saved, not just a large percentage‑off figure.
- If the purchase can wait, monitor the price over time to see whether the holiday sale truly offers the lowest price.
Call for greater pricing transparency
Groundwork Collaborative is also urging retailers to provide clearer pricing information. The organization recommends that sellers display the lowest price a product sold for during the previous 30 days alongside any promotional pricing.
Such transparency would help shoppers quickly determine whether a “Black Friday” or “Cyber Monday” label represents a real bargain or merely a marketing tactic.
Bottom line for consumers
The takeaway is straightforward: a holiday‑sale label does not automatically guarantee the best price. Taking a moment to verify a product’s recent price history can protect shoppers from paying more for a deal that looks good on the screen.
Original reporting: KTNV 13 Action News Las Vegas (local) — read the source article.