Colorado’s 2025 anti‑discrimination statute, known as the Kelly Loving Act, expands protections to include a person’s chosen name and how they wish to be addressed. Jennifer Sey, founder of the women’s‑sports apparel company XX‑XY Athletics, has filed a lawsuit claiming the law could force her business to abandon the language on which it was built.
Legal challenge filed in federal court
Sey’s attorneys, led by Hal Frampton of Alliance Defending Freedom, argue that the law’s definition of gender expression could criminalize statements that refer to transgender‑identifying male athletes by their biological sex. They warn that violations of Colorado’s anti‑discrimination law carry fines up to $3,500 per incident, and certain advertising breaches can be treated as a Class 2 misdemeanor punishable by up to 120 days in jail.
To date, Colorado has not enforced the law against XX‑XY Athletics since its passage in 2025, a point the state uses to argue the company should not receive immediate legal protection while the case proceeds. Nonetheless, Sey remains unconvinced, describing the state’s defense as a “trust me, bro” approach and stating she does not trust Colorado officials.
Background on the Kelly Loving Act and Proposition 134
The Kelly Loving Act was intended to broaden anti‑discrimination coverage to include name and pronoun preferences. Sey’s company, launched in 2024, markets itself as a defender of women’s sports, regularly challenging the participation of biological males in female athletic competitions.
Earlier this year, Sey helped lead a successful campaign for Proposition 134, a ballot measure approved by roughly 52 % of Colorado voters. The measure requires K‑12 and collegiate sports teams to be designated male, female, or coed, with eligibility generally determined by biological sex. It takes effect on Jan. 1.
First‑amendment concerns and court rulings
In March, a federal judge denied XX‑XY Athletics’ request for a preliminary injunction, finding the company had not shown a credible threat of enforcement. The decision did not address whether the Kelly Loving Act violates the First Amendment, leaving the constitutional question open.
State attorney Janna Fischer argues the plaintiffs seek “extraordinary relief” that would allow them to misgender and deadname anyone with impunity, asserting the law does not change substantive rights under the Colorado Anti‑Discrimination Act (CADA). She maintains that the Civil Rights Division looks for conduct rising to the level of harassment, not merely misgendering.
Implications for businesses and free speech
Sey contends the dispute is not just about her company but about all businesses and individuals who may be forced to use language they reject. She warns that if the law stands, “everybody’s afraid to speak the truth.”
Frampton points to prior Supreme Court cases involving Colorado—Masterpiece Cakeshop (2018), 303 Creative (2023), and Chiles v. Salazar (2024)—as precedents protecting expressive rights against state compulsion.
Political context
Colorado’s governor‑elect, Phil Weiser, has suggested that Proposition 134 could face adjustments, noting that as a statute rather than a constitutional amendment, it can be modified by lawmakers. Sey responded that she would “dare him to overturn the will of the people,” indicating a continued clash between the state’s legislative agenda and the business community’s free‑speech concerns.
Original reporting: Fox News (HLL/CB) — read the source article.