At recent Cleveland City Council meetings, officials tackled two pressing local issues: the fire department’s hiring diversity shortfall and a proposed subsidy for Highland Park Golf Course.
During a Nov. 10 Workforce, Education, Training and Youth Development Committee hearing, Committee Chair Richard Starr highlighted that about 75% of fire hires from 2015‑2024 were white men. The division now employs 736 uniformed firefighters, of whom 99 (13.5%) are Black and 18 are women. In the 2023 hiring cycle the department received more than 1,000 applications, with roughly 25% identifying as Black or African American. Over 500 applicants passed the Civil Service Exam, after which a 17‑member Applicant Review Committee ranked the top 72 files. The chief and public‑safety director selected 40 candidates, and the city hired 35 of them.
Fire officials said the hiring process has been adjusted to broaden outreach, including fewer residency documents and hosting the exam at a city‑center testing site. Council members expressed concern that the department manages most of the hiring internally and called for external oversight before the division submits its next budget request, due early in 2027.
In a separate budget‑hearing session, Council members Mike Polensek, Kevin Conwell, Kris Harsh and Brian Kazy voiced strong opposition to a $960,000 (reported as $961,000) subsidy for Highland Park Golf Course. Director of Parks and Recreation Alexandria Nichols and Finance Director Paul Barrett explained that the course projects $1.65 million in revenue against $2.61 million in expenses, creating a $281,000 loss for the current year. The course manager, Tom Sheetz, said the shortfall is expected to reverse by the 2027‑2028 season as new facilities, such as a driving range and additional holes, come online.
Council members also noted that the subsidy supports 18 schools and provides free play for about 160 Cleveland children, a cost the council calculated at roughly $6,000 per child. Critics argued the funds could be better directed to under‑funded parks, playgrounds and recreation centers.
What’s next: The fire department has been asked to present a concrete diversity‑action plan before its early‑2027 budget request. Meanwhile, council will vote on the Highland Park Golf Course subsidy in the upcoming budget session, where members are expected to weigh the financial outlook against community needs.
Sources: signalcleveland.org, signalcleveland.org, signalcleveland.org