Thanksgiving can be a time of gratitude and togetherness without breaking the family budget. Delish food editor Taylor Ann Spencer tested a frugal menu for four people in New York and proved that a full holiday meal can be prepared for under $40.
Smart Turkey Choice
The biggest expense at any Thanksgiving table is the turkey. Spencer opted for a turkey breast tenderloin rather than a whole bird or drumsticks, noting, “You’re paying for the bone. With the tenderloin, you’re eating all of the ounce‑age that you bought.” She seared the tenderloin in a hot pan, basted it with herbs and butter, then finished it in the oven – a technique she likens to cooking a steak. The result is juicy meat without the extra cost of bone.
Homemade Gravy from Pan Drippings
Instead of buying pre‑made gravy, Spencer saved the pan used to sear the turkey to capture the browned bits. She added butter, flour and chicken stock to the drippings, creating a rich, flavorful gravy that complements the tender turkey.
Boxed Stuffing, Elevated
For the stuffing, Spencer started with a boxed mix as a budget‑friendly base. She enhanced it with fresh onion, celery, chicken stock (the same stock used for the gravy), and an egg. The added vegetables and stock give the stuffing depth and moisture while keeping costs low.
Creamy Mashed Potatoes on a Budget
Spencer swapped regular milk for evaporated milk, which she found for $1.25 and noted, “I had trouble finding regular milk that I could get for that amount.” The canned milk provides the same creaminess for a fraction of the price.
Simple Green Beans and Crispy Onion Topping
Rather than a traditional green‑bean casserole, Spencer steamed fresh green beans and used the leftover onions from the stuffing to create a crispy topping. She avoided expensive premade fried‑onion toppings and chose fresh, non‑bagged beans, which saved additional dollars.
Cranberry Sauce Made Easy
For the cranberry sauce, Spencer selected the canned version, which was slightly cheaper than fresh cranberries while still delivering the classic tart flavor.
Mini Apple Crisp Pies Instead of Pumpkin
When it came to dessert, Spencer chose mini apple crisp pies over pumpkin pie because the pumpkin‑pie mix cost $5.99 and would have blown the budget. Each mini pie required only one apple, and the crust and topping were made from pantry staples—flour, butter, sugar, salt and oats.
Final Cost Breakdown
The entire meal for four people totaled $36.11, roughly $9 per person. Spencer emphasizes that planning ahead, relying on pantry staples, and being willing to shop at multiple stores can keep holiday meals affordable without sacrificing flavor.
“Decide what matters to you and then be okay with going to multiple stores to shop,” she advises, encouraging families to prioritize the traditions that matter most while staying financially responsible.
Original reporting: WPBF (Treasure Coast / Hearst) — read the source article.