Broken Arrow city officials announced Wednesday that Police Chief Lance Arnold has been placed on paid leave pending an external investigation into “operational concerns” raised within the department. Deputy Chief Scott Bennett will serve as acting chief while the review proceeds, city manager Michael Spurgeon said.
According to the Broken Arrow Sentinel, the concerns were first brought to Assistant City Manager Norm Stephens late last month. Stephens described the matters as “very concerning” and forwarded them to Spurgeon, who then consulted with Assistant City Manager Kenneth Schwab and the city’s attorneys. Spurgeon declined to detail the specific issues, citing personnel confidentiality, but confirmed that an outside investigator—recommended by the city’s special counsel for personnel—will conduct a “full, fair, and complete evaluation” beginning early next week.
Spurgeon emphasized that the investigation will involve multiple interviews with department personnel and that the findings will be reviewed by Assistant City Manager Stephens, the city’s legal department, and ultimately reported back to the mayor and City Council. He added, “I have not pre‑judged this in any way” and stressed his commitment to transparency within the limits of legal advice.
The Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 170, which represents rank‑and‑file officers, issued a statement backing Chief Arnold, noting that under his leadership the department “has built real momentum, earning wide recognition for our approach to accountability, our adoption of modern technology, and the tools and standards now being brought to this community.” The union also criticized the timing of the announcement, saying officers learned of the leave at the same time as the public.
Spurgeon expressed confidence in Bennett’s ability to lead, recalling that Bennett previously oversaw the department for several months after the retirement of former Chief Brandon Berryhill. “Scott is a true professional. He’s a good leader and police officer who takes his job very seriously,” Spurgeon said, adding that he is concerned about morale but believes Bennett and senior officers can maintain public safety.
The city will update the City Council and the public when appropriate, based on counsel from the city’s attorneys. Residents are urged to remain patient as the investigation proceeds and to continue supporting the department’s mission to keep Broken Arrow safe.
What’s next: The external investigator is expected to begin interviews early next week. Results will be reviewed by city officials before any further action is announced. The City Council will discuss the investigation’s progress at its next regular meeting.
Sources: basentinel.com
