Boise, Idaho – A doctoral student at Boise State University has filed a tort claim seeking at least $1.5 million in damages after the university allegedly refused to assemble the mandatory dissertation committee needed to complete his degree.
Background of the claim
Jeffrey Morgan, who completed all coursework for his Ph.D. in the Public Policy and Administration program with a 4.0 GPA, says his dissertation proposal was rejected and recorded with an F grade. Morgan appealed the grade in the spring, and on April 29 the university acknowledged that programmatic failures contributed to the failing grade and removed it from his transcript, according to the claim filed on Oct. 15.
University’s explanation
Interim program director Jaclyn Kettler wrote to the registrar on April 22, noting that “some program‑level issues contributed to his challenges.” Kettler explained that the university had not offered a key course on developing dissertation proposals when Morgan needed it because of a shortage of faculty. She added that faculty turnover and retirements made it “quite challenging” for Morgan to find a new dissertation chair and committee.
On April 30, the registrar approved the removal of the failing course from Morgan’s transcript, as shown in an email attached to the tort claim.
Impact of the university merger
Boise State is currently merging its College of Education with the School of Public Service, a two‑year process that university officials say will not affect students. Interim dean Andrew Finstuen stated the merger would have no impact on current doctoral candidates. The university declined to comment further on the Ph.D. program, responding through media‑relations director Stephany Galbreaith.
Details of the lawsuit
Morgan’s claim argues that the university offered a transfer option that would force him to lose all credits already earned in the doctoral program. He contends the university’s response was “disingenuous,” leaving him in a “permanent academic blockade.” Morgan estimates lost wages of $1.5 million, based on $60,000 per year for 25 years as a non‑tenure‑track faculty member, and adds $15,000 in student‑loan‑related losses.
What this means for students
The lawsuit highlights potential vulnerabilities for graduate students when institutions face staffing shortages and program restructuring. While the university has removed the failing grade from Morgan’s record, the broader issue of ensuring timely access to required faculty and coursework remains a concern for the Boise State community.
Boise State has not indicated whether it will change its policies or staffing models in response to the claim. The outcome of the lawsuit could set a precedent for how universities handle dissertation committee formation and grade disputes.
Original reporting: Idaho Education News — read the source article.