Arlington County police are facing a federal lawsuit filed by the parents of two 15‑year‑old girls who say they were unlawfully detained and handcuffed at the Pentagon City Mall last year. The suit, filed in federal court, alleges the officers violated the teens’ Fourth Amendment rights by detaining them without probable cause and confiscating their cell phones.
According to NBC Washington, the incident occurred on Presidents Day in 2023 while the girls were waiting for a Metro train. Five Arlington police officers and Metro security approached the teens, accusing them of shoplifting from a Lululemon store inside the Fashion Centre at Pentagon City. One officer allegedly handcuffed a girl when she would not disclose her age, and both girls were taken to the mall’s faregates, where a second officer arrived with a mall employee who quickly told the police the girls were not the suspects. The teens were then released.
“This was a really traumatic experience for both the girls and for their families,” said Madeleine Gates of Washington Lawyers’ Committee, one of the attorneys representing the plaintiffs. Gates emphasized that the girls attempted to explain they had not entered the Lululemon store and that they tried to call their parents, only to have their phones taken away.
The complaint describes the alleged suspects as two short girls, one wearing a pink jacket, while noting that one of the plaintiffs is “about 6‑feet tall, which is notably tall for a 15‑year‑old girl.” The lawsuit seeks $400,000 in damages for the alleged constitutional violations.
Arlington County police, the mall’s general manager, Lululemon, and Metro have not responded to requests for comment, according to the report. Gates said her office has been unable to obtain further details about the shoplifting investigation because the case remains under active investigation.
What’s next: The plaintiffs plan to move forward with the federal case, arguing that the officers’ actions constitute an unlawful search and seizure. The court’s rulings on the suit could set precedent for how law‑enforcement interactions with minors are handled in public spaces throughout Arlington. Residents awaiting the outcome are encouraged to follow court filings for updates.
Sources: nbcwashington.com, nbcwashington.com, nbcwashington.com