On Nov. 21, 2026 President Donald Trump told Fox News’ “Saturday in America” that outgoing Texas Sen. John Cornyn is doing a “tremendous disservice” by blocking his pick for a lifetime federal judgeship in Dallas. The seat in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas has been vacant since 2025, leaving Dallas residents without a local district judge.
The nominee, T. Elliot Gaiser, is a senior Department of Justice lawyer who previously served as Ohio’s solicitor general. According to the New York Post, Gaiser clerked for Justice Sam Alito and currently heads the Office of Legal Counsel, the president’s senior constitutional advisor.
Senate tradition requires home‑state senators to return a “blue slip” to allow a judicial nominee to proceed. Cornyn has refused to return the slip, arguing that the White House nominated a non‑Texan without proper consultation or trial‑court experience. He posted on X questioning why President Trump waited until after the midterms to make the nomination.
Sen. Ted Cruz, also a Texas Republican, called Cornyn’s move “really frustrating.” Cruz told Fox News he approached Cornyn on the Senate floor and was denied a meeting, saying Republicans had agreed to confirm as many judges as possible before Democrats take control in January, but a new nominee would need weeks for an FBI background check.
Heritage Foundation President Kevin Roberts criticized Cornyn on X, calling his actions a “legacy” that helps a “radical leftist” agenda and praising Gaiser as “one of the most brilliant legal minds of this generation.”
If the Dallas seat stays open into the new Congress, the incoming Democratic Senate will control the confirmation vote, and the new Texas senator James Talarico—who defeated Ken Paxton on Nov. 3—will be one of the two home‑state senators consulted.
What’s next: Cornyn said he is willing to work with the White House on a candidate who can clear an FBI background check quickly, but the White House has not announced a new nominee. Unless the Senate confirms a judge before the new Congress convenes, the Dallas district court seat is expected to remain vacant through the end of the year.
Sources: wbap.com, nypost.com