A Seminole County jury on Thursday returned guilty verdicts against 55‑year‑old John Nolte II for the 2023 murder of Jacob Washington. The jury found Nolte guilty on every charge presented, including first‑degree murder, conspiracy to commit arson and two counts of filing false insurance claims.
Background of the case
Jacob Washington was reported missing in May 2022. After a search, his body was discovered with gunshot wounds. Court documents revealed that Washington had been employed by Nolte, working on a barn on Nolte’s property. Nolte allegedly suspected Washington of involvement in a burglary at his home, a suspicion that later became a motive in the prosecution’s case.
The prosecution also presented evidence that a barn where Washington had been working burned down, linking the arson charge to the murder case. Two insurance policies filed after the fire were deemed fraudulent, adding to the charges against Nolte.
Family reactions
Washington’s family shared heartfelt memories during the sentencing hearing. Georgia Washington, Jacob’s mother, said, “Building was his passion; he loved to build, and he loved his family, his family meant everything to him. He loved to fish; he loved to play guitar.”
His sister, Chelsea Washington, added, “As Jake and I got older, Jake became my best friend, so losing him — it has destroyed our whole family.” Their grandmother, Barbara Washington, recalled, “He loved everybody; if he were here today, he’d welcome you with all his heart.”
Next steps
Nolte’s sentencing has not yet been set; a hearing is scheduled for January, where the judge will determine the length of his prison term and any additional penalties related to the arson and insurance fraud convictions.
The case underscores the seriousness with which Seminole County law‑enforcement and prosecutors pursue violent crime, especially when it involves betrayal of trust within a community. Residents expressed relief that the judicial process has moved forward and that justice is being served for the Washington family.
Local officials reminded citizens that any information related to ongoing investigations should be reported promptly to law‑enforcement agencies. The county continues to encourage community cooperation to keep neighborhoods safe.
Original reporting: Oklahoma City News Feed (HLL/CB) — read the source article.