Marion County, Fla. – A local jury delivered a decisive verdict on Monday, finding 54‑year‑old auto shop owner Dwain Chadwick Hall guilty of premeditated first‑degree murder and kidnapping in the death of Sonia Exelby, a 32‑year‑old British visitor who vanished after arriving in Florida last October.
Investigation traced the crime from England to Marion County
Interpol alerted the Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE) on October 13, 2025, after Hampshire & Isle of Wight police reported Exelby missing. Credit‑card records led investigators to an Airbnb rental in Reddick, Florida, where further financial clues linked Hall’s auto‑repair business to the case.
Cell‑phone data and airport logs showed Hall picking up Exelby in Gainesville and driving her to the Reddick rental. Investigators also uncovered that Hall had purchased rope and a shovel before Exelby’s flight arrived, and later mailed a knife to an out‑of‑state friend, which was intercepted and tied to the murder.
Body discovered and forensic evidence
Four days after the search began, a joint team of FDLE agents, Marion County Sheriff’s detectives, and British authorities located Exelby’s body buried in a wooded area of Marion Oaks. Crime‑scene technicians recovered a shovel label that matched a receipt and surveillance video of Hall buying the tool. The same shovel was later found in Hall’s home with Exelby’s blood on the handle. An autopsy confirmed she died from four sharp‑force injuries.
Sentencing and community response
Judge Timothy McCourt sentenced Hall to two consecutive life terms without the possibility of parole. Fifth Judicial Circuit State Attorney Bill Gladson said the case was “extraordinary and deeply disturbing,” expressing hope that the verdict would bring some measure of justice and healing to Exelby’s family.
Assistant State Attorneys Amy Berndt and Richard Buxman led the prosecution, supported by Marion County Sheriff’s Detective Joseph Miller and FDLE lead investigator Rebekah McKinzie under FDLE Commissioner Larry Keefe.
The case underscores the importance of international cooperation and vigilant law‑enforcement work in protecting vulnerable travelers.
Original reporting: Tampa Free Press — read the source article.