My friend Dana swears by the corned beef hash. She’s been coming here since she moved to the Marmalade neighborhood in 2011, and she told me once that she judges a breakfast spot by whether the cook gives a damn about the potatoes. At Penny Ann’s, she says, they clearly do.
I didn’t have the hash the first time I went. I had the stuffed French toast, and I’ve been thinking about it on and off for three years. It’s thick brioche, split and filled with sweetened cream cheese, griddled until the outside has that faint resistance and the inside goes soft and warm. They dust it with powdered sugar and hand you real maple syrup on the side. It costs somewhere around twelve dollars and takes about fifteen minutes to arrive, which is enough time to drink half a cup of coffee and notice that almost every table around you is a regular.
Penny Ann herself — Penny Ann Larsen — opened the place in the early 2000s and still shows up most mornings. She’s not hidden in a back office. If you sit at the counter, which I’d recommend, you’ll probably see her moving between the kitchen and the floor, checking in with people by name, refilling coffee without being asked. That kind of ownership is rarer than it should be. The place is small — maybe forty seats, counting the counter — and the walls are covered in that specific way that says real accumulation over time rather than deliberate decoration.
The cafe sits on 200 North, just west of downtown, in a stretch that’s part residential and part light commercial. It’s not a neighborhood that gets a lot of food press, which is probably why Penny Ann’s keeps flying under most people’s radar. Parking on the street is usually fine, and the walk from the nearest TRAX stop is about ten minutes.
Beyond the French toast, the benedicts are worth your attention. The classic is straightforward and good, but the smoked salmon version is what I’d push a first-timer toward — bright, a little briny, with a hollandaise that isn’t so rich it shuts you down before noon. The portions are honest without being absurd. You’ll leave full but not wrecked.
Expect a wait on weekend mornings. It starts forming around 8:30 and can run twenty or thirty minutes by 10. Weekday mornings are calmer; I’ve walked in on a Tuesday at 8:00 and sat down immediately. Hours run roughly 7 a.m. to 2 p.m., though I’d confirm before you go — they close when they’re out, which on busy days can be earlier than the posted time.
The price point is honest Salt Lake City breakfast: most plates fall between ten and fifteen dollars. Cash is welcome, card is fine. The coffee is diner coffee done right — hot, strong, bottomless.
Dana is correct about the potatoes, by the way. I finally ordered the hash on my fourth visit. The potatoes are crispy where they should be, tender where they should be, and seasoned like someone thought about it. That sounds like a low bar. It isn’t.