MINOT, N.D. – A state‑wide audit released this week uncovered serious compliance gaps in North Dakota’s bioscience grant program. The review showed that over half of the money disbursed to participating firms did not meet the program’s eligibility rules.
Eligibility rules and audit findings
The bioscience grant program was designed to help local companies grow and create jobs. To qualify, a firm must operate in North Dakota, be registered with the state, employ at least two people, and have annual sales below $2.5 million.
State Auditor Josh Gallion explained that his team cross‑checked grant applications and supporting documentation against those criteria. The audit identified one company that received just over $1 million but never opened its planned site in Fargo. A broader review uncovered nine additional recipients that lacked a physical presence in the state.
Comments from state officials
Gallion quoted a legal opinion stating that, “as a practical matter, it would be hard for most businesses to meet the requirement of operating in the state without having some sort of physical presence.” He added that the department had already canceled a separate grant after discovering a lack of North Dakota business presence and alleged misrepresentation.
Agriculture Commissioner Doug Goehring argued that working with a North Dakota business or university can satisfy the “operating here” requirement. He cited CorVent Medical, which took several years to relocate its manufacturing operations to the state, as an example of a company that eventually complied.
Goehring also noted that a third‑party contractor hired by the agriculture department had verified the companies’ eligibility before the proposals were submitted. “We didn’t have a formal checklist. Absolutely true. But were they eligible? Under the criteria, what the law says, yes, they were,” he said.
Financial repercussions and next steps
The audit found that six of the nine sampled recipients could not provide proof that their annual sales were below the $2.5 million threshold. The department has already reimbursed companies for work completed under their grant agreements. In one case, a firm left the state before finishing its project, and the department required repayment for the portion of the grant tied to unfinished work.
Goehring confirmed that the department is now reviewing past awards and has added a formal checklist to verify eligibility going forward. Gallion said the department will decide whether to seek additional repayments from the disqualified recipients.
Legislative oversight
Lawmakers on the Legislature’s audit review committee are scheduled to hear the report on November 30. The bioscience grant program currently has no future funding. Goehring indicated that if legislators choose to revive the program, they should clarify the residency and sales requirements to prevent similar issues.
This audit underscores the importance of rigorous oversight for state‑funded economic development initiatives. By tightening eligibility verification, North Dakota aims to ensure that grant dollars support truly local businesses and generate the promised jobs and growth.
Original reporting: KFYR-TV Bismarck (news) — read the source article.