A Darke County jury delivered a verdict on Thursday that brings closure to a tragic fire that claimed the life of 86‑year‑old Beverly Lees. The jury found 37‑year‑old Jamin Brenner guilty of two counts of aggravated murder and two counts of aggravated arson, according to records from the Darke County Common Pleas Court.
Background of the incident
On December 12, 2024, deputies and fire crews responded to a blaze at the Sherwood Forest Trailer Community in Darke County. While battling the flames, firefighters discovered Lees inside the home. She was pronounced dead at the scene. Investigators quickly determined that the fire had been intentionally set.
Connection to the defendant
Law enforcement identified Brenner as the grandson of the victim. He had been living in the same residence where the fire erupted. After a multi‑state investigation, Brenner was located and arrested in Dayton in June 2025 and is currently held in the Darke County Jail.
Trial and conviction
The trial, which drew significant community attention, presented evidence that Brenner deliberately set the fire that killed his grandmother. The jury deliberated and returned a unanimous guilty verdict on all four charges. The court will schedule Brenner’s sentencing for this afternoon, with the presiding judge expected to impose a lengthy prison term consistent with Ohio law for aggravated murder and arson.
Community response
Residents of Darke County expressed sorrow and relief that the case has reached a conclusion. “We’re grateful for the hard work of our law‑enforcement officers and the dedication of the fire department,” said a spokesperson for the Darke County Sheriff’s Office. “Justice has been served for Ms. Lees and her family.”
Next steps
Brenner’s sentencing is set for later today on News Center 7 at 5:00 p.m. The community will continue to watch the proceedings closely, as the case underscores the importance of swift investigative work and the role of the judicial system in addressing violent crimes.
Original reporting: WHIO-TV Dayton (local) — read the source article.