On Thursday, the Fourth Judicial District Court in Sheridan handed down a prison sentence for 40‑year‑old David Amey after he pleaded no contest to a charge of incest. The case stemmed from an investigation that began after the Sheridan Police Department responded to an infant death at Sheridan Memorial Hospital on April 3, 2024.
Background of the investigation
The infant, born premature, died of health complications. While the death was initially treated as a medical tragedy, detectives uncovered evidence suggesting a sexual crime involving a family member. The investigation led to Amey’s arrest on March 26, 2026.
Plea agreement and sentencing
At a change‑of‑plea hearing on September 10, Amey entered a no‑contest plea as part of a plea agreement negotiated with state prosecutors. The agreement called for a prison term of eight to twelve years, a modest $275 in court costs and assessments, and a credit of 240 days for time already served in pre‑sentence confinement.
District Court Judge Ben Kirvan described the facts and circumstances of the case as “deeply disturbing” before adopting the plea‑agreement recommendations. He emphasized that the sentence reflects the seriousness of the offense while also accounting for Amey’s time already spent in custody.
Community response
Local residents expressed shock and concern over the case, noting the impact such crimes have on families and the broader community. While the details of the incident remain private to protect the surviving family members, community leaders reiterated the importance of safeguarding children and supporting victims of abuse.
Legal context
Incest is a felony under Wyoming law, carrying significant prison terms and mandatory restitution. The sentencing aligns with state statutes that aim to deter sexual abuse within families and provide justice for victims.
The court’s decision also underscores the role of the Sheridan Police Department and local prosecutors in investigating and prosecuting serious crimes, reinforcing public safety priorities in the region.
Next steps
Amey will be transferred to a state correctional facility to begin serving his sentence. The court ordered that he remain on supervised release after his prison term, subject to conditions set by the Wyoming Department of Corrections.
Authorities encourage anyone with information about similar crimes to contact the Sheridan Police Department or the Wyoming Division of Criminal Investigation.
Original reporting: Sheridan Media (Sheridan WY) — read the source article.