Boise’s Planning and Zoning Department recently approved a conditional use permit and several variances for a proposed five‑cottage rental project—known as Wilson Cottage Court—on a half‑acre lot on South Wilson Street in the Boise Bench neighborhood. While the approvals address technical details such as parking placement, landscaping buffers and setback requirements, a group of nearby residents has formally appealed the decisions, arguing that the project may strain the narrow, one‑way dead‑end street.
Details of the approved permits
The city’s approval focused on three key items:
- Location of on‑site parking, which the developer says is limited by a 30‑foot irrigation district easement along the north side of the property.
- Minimum landscaping buffer, which the variance would reduce from five feet to roughly three feet, eight inches.
- Setback distances from the property line, ensuring the cottages sit within the city’s zoning standards.
Land Architect, the developer, noted that the easement restricts driveway and parking options, and the project still meets the city’s requirement of one parking space per cottage.
Neighbors’ concerns
Bob Johnson, who lives directly across from the lot, said the code should be revisited. “Five is too much. Take it down to three, we could live with it,” he told the planning commission.
Katherine Barker, another resident, highlighted traffic worries. “We have traffic turning around in our private driveways. It’s part of living on a dead end, but usually dead ends are designed to accommodate smaller amounts of residential traffic.”
Erin Scuglia, a neighbor with young adults still living at home, expressed a balanced view. “We’re not opposed to housing at all. It’s just that the size of the property and the street don’t seem reasonable for five cottages.”
Property owner’s response
Guy Skeele, the property owner, emphasized his intent to provide market‑rate rentals while keeping them affordable under existing city rules. “The best policy is always to find a way to get along with them. Always be the best neighbor you can,” Skeele said.
He also noted that the developer has attempted to secure additional parking space for storage and visitors, but the irrigation easement limits those options.
Access and easement dispute
One family that currently uses part of the lot as a driveway to a garage raised concerns about a potential loss of access. The developer argued that no recorded easement exists to guarantee that right of way, and negotiations have not produced an agreement.
Next steps
The appeals will be reviewed by the City Council, which will decide whether to uphold the Planning and Zoning Department’s approvals or require further modifications. The council’s decision could set a precedent for how Boise handles similar cottage‑village projects in existing neighborhoods.
Boise’s growth strategy includes encouraging smaller, higher‑density developments like cottage courts to address the city’s housing shortage. The Wilson Cottage Court case illustrates the tension between expanding housing options and preserving the character and safety of established neighborhoods.
Residents who wish to comment on the appeal are encouraged to attend the upcoming council hearing or submit written statements to the city clerk’s office.
Original reporting: KIVI Idaho News 6 Boise metro (local) — read the source article.