Henry County, Indiana – On Oct. 26, 2026, Spiceland resident Elvante Riddick filed a three‑page Notice of Tort Claim under the Indiana Tort Claims Act against Sheriff John Sproles, the county commissioners, and senior IT staff. Riddick alleges the sheriff’s office illegally denied his public‑records request for audit logs that would reveal how often deputies and jail personnel accessed his personal data in the department’s Spillman and Mobile Data Terminal (MDT) systems.
Background of the dispute
Riddick says the conflict began with a 2023 traffic stop that escalated into a disputed impersonation charge, an arrest on a nonexistent warrant, and a series of background checks by officers he never met. He describes the back‑and‑forth with the sheriff’s office as “like a game of chess,” noting that each of his actions was met with a counter‑move from Sheriff Sproles.
Public‑records request denied
On April 28, 2026, Riddick submitted a written request under the Indiana Access to Public Records Act (APRA) for logs showing every time his name or identifying information was queried in the Spillman and MDT systems. The same day, Deputy John Guy responded by email, stating, “Our office’s use of Spillman is not a public record,” and claiming that providing the logs would require creating a new document. Guy also said the department had stopped providing such records after discussions with the county attorney’s office and the Indiana Public Access Counselor.
Riddick points out that the sheriff’s office had previously complied with an almost identical request covering July 2023 to July 2024, delivering the full set of logs. He argues that the sudden denial contradicts that earlier cooperation.
Allegations in the tort claim
The claim asserts that the department violated Indiana Code § 5‑14‑3‑9 by failing to cite a specific statutory exemption for the denial. It also alleges negligence, negligent supervision, unauthorized access to personal information, misuse of government computer systems, and intentional misconduct.
Riddick says the withheld records show his name was queried 61 times over a one‑year period, involving not only road deputies but also court deputies and jail officers—people he has never encountered. He emphasizes that each query can reveal full criminal histories, Social Security numbers, and child‑support status, effectively exposing his entire personal profile.
Potential damages and preservation order
Because the records remain unavailable, Riddick cannot yet calculate a precise monetary loss. The claim nevertheless includes a spoliation and evidence‑preservation notice, ordering county officials to suspend any automatic deletion policies and to preserve all relevant logs, login data, dispatch records, emails, and communications with the Indiana Public Access Counselor.
Broader context of lawsuits against the sheriff’s office
Riddick’s filing adds to at least a dozen tort claims and multiple federal civil‑rights lawsuits lodged against the Henry County Sheriff’s Office since Sproles took office in 2023. Earlier cases include a Jan. 2024 claim by Diane Baker, who alleged three unauthorized database lookups after she criticized Sproles on social media, and a separate suit accusing the sheriff of labeling a resident a “known gang member” without basis.
By mid‑2024, the volume of claims prompted the county’s liability insurer to terminate coverage, forcing taxpayers to purchase supplemental insurance at an additional cost of $230,000 and raising the per‑incident deductible from $25,000 to $150,000.
Political backdrop
In the May 5, 2026 Republican primary, Sheriff Sproles lost his bid for re‑election, finishing second with 29.55% of the vote behind James “Jim” Nicholson, who secured the GOP nomination with 41.37%. Nicholson won the Nov. 3, 2026 general election and will assume office at the start of the new term.
Despite the upcoming transition, Riddick says he remains determined to obtain the records, fearing retaliation based on past experiences. “My biggest concern is, in the past, they’ve always retaliated,” he told WIBC. “I just want to hold them accountable and stop hiding behind closed doors.”
What’s next?
The tort claim now moves through the Indiana courts, where a judge will decide whether the sheriff’s office must produce the requested logs and whether any statutory violations occurred. County officials have been instructed to preserve all relevant electronic records pending the court’s ruling.
Original reporting: 93.1 WIBC (Indianapolis) — read the source article.