Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrian publicly declared she will not comply with U.S. District Judge Annemarie Axon’s order requiring a “robust, heartfelt” apology to the Southeastern Conference (SEC). The judge, appointed by President Trump in 2017, said the AG and Louisiana State University must issue news releases correcting the AG’s claim that the SEC’s citations were “hallucinated,” a term usually reserved for AI‑generated content.
Background of the dispute
The conflict stems from the SEC’s lawsuit against LSU for attempting to add former professional basketball players to its roster, a move the conference says violates its membership rules. The SEC has threatened to expel LSU but ultimately chose not to punish the university for the specific addition.
During the litigation, Murrian’s office alleged that the SEC’s legal citations were fabricated, prompting Judge Axon to order the apology. Murrian responded on social media, stating, “I cannot and will not apologize for my lawyers doing their job, and it is improper for an Alabama federal judge to compel speech from the State of Louisiana.” She added that the SEC’s citation error is the league’s problem, not Louisiana’s.
State officials weigh in
Governor Jeff Landry also weighed in, describing the judge as an “University of Alabama alumni” who should step aside from SEC politics. He called the lawsuit “frivolous” and a waste of court time and state resources.
Legal experts noted that the judge’s order raises significant First Amendment concerns. Attorney Scott Sternberg, a specialist in free‑speech issues, said, “Any time the government, including the court, tells you what to say, it certainly raises constitutional questions.” He suggested that requiring a press release may be “a bridge too far” and that similar cases are rare.
Potential legal consequences
Attorney Scott Schneider, an education and employment law expert, warned that Murrian’s refusal could lead Judge Axon to summon the AG and Solicitor General Ben Aguiñaga to explain the alleged “hallucinations” in court. The judge’s letter followed a hearing in Birmingham where LSU added former pro player RJ Luis to its basketball roster after a state judge ordered the inclusion.
The SEC rebuked LSU’s move as inconsistent with conference expectations but chose not to impose sanctions, highlighting the ongoing tension between the league’s rules and recent NCAA changes that allow athletes to compete for up to five years.
Implications for Louisiana
The standoff underscores a broader clash between state officials and federal courts over perceived overreach. Murrian’s stance frames the order as compelled speech, aligning with Governor Landry’s emphasis on protecting state sovereignty and individual liberty.
As the case proceeds, both the AG’s office and the SEC will likely continue to exchange legal filings, with the outcome potentially setting a precedent for how courts can mandate public apologies in disputes involving state officials.
Original reporting: KTBS 3 (Shreveport) — read the source article.