Overland Park, Kansas – A local homeowner who lost $2,750 to a fraudulent masonry contractor has been made whole after the police department reopened her case following a television report. Caitlin Locklear hired Malakai Skinner of Skinner’s Masonry in November 2024 to repair a fallen brick wall on her garage. She paid half of the $5,500 estimate via Venmo, but Skinner never returned to complete the work and disappeared with the money.
Initial complaint and stalled investigation
When Locklear first reported the incident, Overland Park police classified it as a civil matter and closed the file. Unable to serve a small‑claims lawsuit because Skinner listed multiple invalid addresses, Locklear turned to the local news station KSHB 41 for help. Her story aired in July 2025, warning other residents about the contractor’s questionable business practices.
Police reopen the case
Following the broadcast, Overland Park police reopened the investigation in September 2025. Public information officer John Lacy explained that new information surfaced, prompting a deeper look. “Sometimes when we get an original report, it evolves,” Lacy said. “There were more layers regarding this particular case, and our investigations team took a closer look.”
In October 2025, officers arrested Skinner and charged him with felony theft by deception. The case moved forward, and on November 4, 2026, Skinner entered a plea agreement, pleading guilty to a reduced misdemeanor charge of deceptive commercial practices. As part of the deal, he was ordered to return the full $2,750 to Locklear.
Victim receives restitution
Locklear received a check for the full amount and described the moment as “disbelief” and “pure joy.” She ran to the bank immediately and celebrated when the funds cleared the next day. “I can’t thank you guys enough for helping me get my money back,” she said, crediting the news report and the police department’s persistence.
Broader implications for consumers
Officer Lacy noted that contractor fraud is a recurring problem in Overland Park and urged residents to file police reports promptly, even if the dispute seems civil. Early reporting can create a paper trail that law‑enforcement can use if the situation escalates to criminal conduct.
The investigation also uncovered a similar complaint from a woman in Wyandotte County, indicating that Skinner may have a pattern of walking away from jobs after receiving payment. While that case remains separate, it underscores the need for vigilance when hiring local service providers.
Community response
Local residents praised the outcome, emphasizing the role of community journalism in prompting official action. “It does make me feel good to see a resolution,” Officer Lacy said. “Something like this, we don’t hear about it too often.” The story serves as a reminder that media exposure combined with diligent police work can protect consumers and hold dishonest contractors accountable.
For anyone facing a similar situation, the Overland Park Police Department recommends documenting all communications, retaining receipts, and reporting suspected fraud as soon as possible. These steps increase the likelihood of recovery and help prevent future scams in the community.
Original reporting: KSHB 41 Kansas City (local) — read the source article.