On Tuesday, the New Haven Board of Education’s Grievance Committee voted 3‑0 to deny the grievance filed by the School Administrators Association (SAA). The union argued that the district’s bus schedule drops off students up to an hour before the first bell and picks them up after the official dismissal, creating a safety risk and an extra supervisory burden for administrators.
Union’s Concerns
SAA President Tara Cass presented data showing that 36 schools are affected. She reported that 742 of the district’s 1,168 buses arrive outside the window that allows adequate supervision, forcing principals or assistant principals to watch large groups of students without teacher or paraprofessional support. In some cases, administrators are supervising as many as 200 students in a cafeteria.
Cass noted that the district’s contract provides paraprofessionals with a 15‑minute buffer before and after school hours, teachers work six hours and 45 minutes, while administrators have an eight‑hour workday. She argued that the early arrivals and late pick‑ups add duties that were not contemplated in those contracts.
Board’s Rationale
Board members Abie Benitez, Matt Wilcox, and Daniel Juarez, who chaired the temporary subcommittee, found that “no specific provision was breached.” They emphasized that the grievance does not alter the administrators’ contractual eight‑hour workday. City attorney Michael Barrera reinforced this view, stating that the majority of buses arrive within the administrators’ normal work hours and that occasional unscheduled activities are already covered by contract language.
Barrera also pointed out that the union’s right to bargain on the issue does not guarantee a grievance win; “what wasn’t won at the bargaining table can’t be won in grievance,” he said.
Data on Bus Timing
According to the district’s run sheets, 551 of 590 afternoon buses arrive outside the supervision window, and 191 of 578 morning buses arrive more than ten minutes early. Specific schools cited by the union include Barnard, Beecher, Metropolitan Business Academy, High School in the Community, Betsy Ross, and Mauro Sheridan, which received funding for additional supervision coverage on September 22. However, Cass said the bus schedule at each of those schools remains uncorrected.
At Barnard, the official schedule calls for buses to arrive at 8:50 a.m. and depart at 3:45 p.m., yet buses often pull in at 8:36 a.m. and leave around 4:14 p.m. In the most extreme cases, buses arrived as early as 7:40 a.m. on September 1‑11, well before the 9:00 a.m. start time.
Administrative Impact
Clinton Avenue School Principal and SAA Secretary Jaime Coady recounted an incident on October 27 when she was called at 5:00 p.m. to handle a student whose parent was not at the bus stop. Her eight‑hour day had already ended, yet she stayed to supervise until the student was picked up at 5:45 p.m.
Cass concluded by urging the board to use the existing $124 million First Student contract—approximately $31.2 million per year—to align bus run times with school bell schedules. She suggested that proper contract management could generate savings that might help close the district’s budget deficit.
Board’s Next Steps
Board member Matt Wilcox asked why the union agreed to its latest contract without securing language changes. Cass responded that the board had promised a collaborative working group to gather more information before any contractual amendment could be drafted.
While the grievance was denied, the board acknowledged the ongoing concern and indicated that the district will continue to monitor bus timing and explore ways to improve supervision without imposing additional contractual obligations on administrators.
Original reporting: New Haven Independent — read the source article.