Washington and Oregon lawmakers are scrutinizing the selection of a single joint venture, Columbia River Constructors, to design the massive Interstate 5 bridge replacement that will span the Columbia River. The consortium—comprised of Guy F. Atkinson Construction, Traylor Bros. Inc. and Kiewit Engineering Group—was the only design bid received in late September.
Cost‑overrun history raises red flags
Kiewit, a subsidiary of Nebraska‑based Kiewit Corp, is one of the nation’s largest contractors but has recently been tied to costly overruns. The firm is building the Interstate 205 Abernathy Bridge in Oregon City, a project now more than two years behind schedule and with an estimated cost of $800 million—over three times the original $250 million budget, according to KGW.
Maryland recently removed Kiewit from the second phase of rebuilding the Francis Scott Key Bridge after the firm’s price and timeline were deemed “unreasonably high and therefore unacceptable,” Governor Wes Moore said.
State performance reviews and past overruns
Oregon’s Department of Transportation gave Kiewit negative marks on four consecutive annual reviews dating back to 2022, raising further concerns about the contractor’s reliability. In 2024 the company was hired to design the Hood River‑White Salmon Bridge Replacement, a project that has since more than doubled in price to over $1.2 billion, partly due to underestimated drilled‑shaft costs, according to economist Joe Cortright of the City Observatory think tank.
Legislators demand accountability
During a joint legislative committee meeting, Rep. Thủy Trần (D‑Portland) and Sen. Bruce Starr (R‑Dundee) asked program administrators how they would hold Kiewit and its partners accountable and manage the soaring costs. The Interstate Bridge Replacement Program, originally projected at up to $7.5 billion in 2022, now carries a price tag near $14.4 billion, officials announced in March.
Washington Gov. Bob Ferguson said a construction contract is expected next year, with traffic potentially crossing the new span by 2035—about two years later than earlier estimates.
Design‑build approach aims for cost certainty
State transportation official John White explained that the project will use a progressive design‑build delivery method, which brings the owner, designer and contractor together early to improve cost certainty and pricing transparency.
Rep. Ed Orcutt (R‑Kalama), co‑chair of the joint committee, echoed the need for competition: “Having multiple bidders is important to protect the taxpayers. If you only have one bidder, they can bid whatever they want. Either we pay them or we don’t get the project.”
Supporters argue limited bidders are inevitable
Some legislators see the joint venture as a practical solution. Rep. Susan McLain (D‑Forest Grove) noted that few firms possess the capacity and experience required for a project of this magnitude, and that a small number of submitters is common for large infrastructure work. She emphasized the bridge’s seismic resilience as critical to the region’s safety and economic well‑being.
Rep. Jake Fey (D‑Tacoma), chair of the House Transportation Committee, acknowledged the preference for multiple bidders but said the market sometimes forces collaboration: “There were two firms that were interested and they decided to collaborate. What are you going to do? If you can’t make a deal with them, then we go back to the process of seeking qualified bidders.”
Economist warns of bargaining disadvantages
Cortright warned lawmakers that dealing with a single contractor puts the two states in a weak bargaining position, citing the Abernathy Bridge overruns as evidence that Kiewit “goes over budget” and is difficult to negotiate with.
Kiewit spokesperson Bob Kula declined to comment on future pursuits but affirmed the firm’s “long track record delivering complex transportation projects across the U.S.”
What’s next?
The committee will continue to monitor cost estimates and seek ways to ensure transparency and accountability as the design phase moves forward. Stakeholders hope the progressive design‑build approach will keep the project on schedule and within budget, but lawmakers remain vigilant about the potential for further overruns.
Original reporting: Clark County Today (Vancouver WA) — read the source article.