Everybody in Montgomery who grew up eating tamales has a Johnson’s story. Mine involves my grandmother sending me across town with a folded ten-dollar bill and instructions not to come back without a dozen. I was eleven. That was 1994. Jimmy Lee Johnson was already a fixture on Rosa L. Parks Avenue by then, running the kind of place that doesn’t advertise because it doesn’t need to.
Jimmy started making tamales out of his house in the mid-1980s, the story goes, before moving into the small storefront on Rosa L. Parks where he’s operated ever since. The building looks like it has been there forever — painted concrete block, a hand-lettered sign out front, a screen door that swings on a spring hinge. If you’re driving by and don’t know what you’re looking for, you’ll miss it. If you do know, you’ll probably pull over too fast.
What Jimmy makes are wet tamales — not the tight, dry masa rolls you find at Mexican restaurants, but the loose, deeply savory Delta-style tamale that traveled up from Mississippi and took root across the Deep South. The masa is thin and soft, the filling is spiced pork, and the whole thing arrives in a cup of its own broth, warm and a little oily in the best possible way. You eat them with a spoon if you’re sensible. You eat them with your hands if you’re not.
A dozen runs about eight or nine dollars. You can get a half-dozen if you’re not sure, but I’ve never met anyone who ordered a half-dozen and didn’t immediately wish they’d gotten the full twelve. There’s also a beef version, though the pork is what people come for. The menu is small by design — tamales, some sides, cold drinks from a cooler near the register. That’s about it.
What keeps me coming back, beyond the food itself, is Jimmy. He’s in his seventies now and still working the counter most days, still wearing the same kind of white apron, still taking orders in that unhurried way of his, like he has nowhere else to be and neither do you. He remembers faces. He remembers orders. I brought a friend from Birmingham last spring who’d never been, and within two visits Jimmy was already calling her by name.
The neighborhood around Rosa L. Parks Avenue has changed around him over the years — some blocks improved, others not — but Johnson’s has stayed constant. There are no Yelp deals, no Instagram-ready presentations, no pivot to catering. It is exactly what it was forty years ago, which I mean as a genuine compliment.
Go on a weekday if you can. Weekends can get crowded and sometimes they sell out earlier than you’d expect. Cash is preferred, though Jimmy usually keeps a card reader around somewhere. Plan to eat in the car or take them home fast — tamales cool quickly and they’re best when the broth is still steaming.
Montgomery has a lot of food worth eating. This one matters in a different way. Some things just don’t get replaced.