Former acting mayor of Buffalo, Christopher Scanlon, told the Common Council that the city could not afford to schedule a police recruitment exam during his tenure because of a significant budget deficit. Scanlon, who served as acting mayor from October 2024 through December 2025, said the city faced a $70 million shortfall that left no resources for the exam.
Staffing pressures mount
The Buffalo Police Department (BPD) is already feeling the strain. A recent 7 News investigation found that overtime usage rose 65 percent in fiscal year 2025‑2026 compared with the prior year as the department tries to meet minimum staffing levels. Police Union President John Davidson warned that retirements are outpacing recruitment, predicting a “mass exodus” at the end of this year and into early 2026 if hiring does not improve.
According to Davidson, 19 officers have retired this year, five have resigned, and seven more plan to retire by year‑end. The next police exam is slated for the end of April 2027, meaning a new class of officers will not be on the streets until sometime in 2028 at the earliest.
Previous exam and pause
The city’s last police recruitment exam was held in 2023. Police Commissioner Erika Shields previously blamed the three‑year pause for the department’s staffing woes, a view echoed by Human Resources Commissioner Gladys Herndon‑Hill, who said, “We should have had an exam last year.” Herndon‑Hill added that the list of potential recruits from the 2023 exam is now exhausted.
When asked why an exam was not held in 2025, Scanlon explained that the process can take months to schedule and that the decision had to be made earlier than his tenure to have taken place. He suggested that the responsibility lay with his predecessor, Mayor Byron Brown.
Looking ahead
Commissioner Shields has indicated the city hopes to draw from Erie County’s list of potential recruits to add officers before 2028. Herndon‑Hill said the city aims to place a class from that list into the police academy in January, though Davidson expressed skepticism, calling a January hire “a miracle.”
The council will continue to monitor the department’s staffing situation and consider options to address the recruitment gap while balancing the city’s fiscal constraints.
Original reporting: WKBW 7 Buffalo (Buffalo section) — read the source article.