West Virginia’s attorney general, J.B. McCuskey, filed a motion on Friday with the state Supreme Court to dismiss a lawsuit that challenges the current public‑school funding formula. The suit, originally brought on behalf of a Lincoln County student, alleges that the formula does not satisfy the constitutional duty to provide an efficient public‑school system.
Legal arguments focus on legislative immunity
In his filing, McCuskey contended that members of the House of Delegates and Senate, including Senate President Randy Smith and House Speaker Roger Hanshaw, are protected by legislative immunity for actions taken in their official capacities. He argued that the legislators cannot be sued for passing, amending, or declining to amend the school‑funding formula.
Standing and additional defendants
The motion also asserts that the plaintiff lacks standing to sue, further weakening the case. Alongside Smith and Hanshaw, the lawsuit names several other state officials and entities: State Auditor Mark Hunt, Tax Commissioner Matthew Irby, State Treasurer Larry Pack, the Department of Education, the Board of Education, the School Building Authority, State School Superintendent Michelle Blatt, and Lincoln County school‑board officials.
Background on the funding formula
West Virginia’s school‑aid formula ties state aid directly to student enrollment numbers. Critics have argued that the model has not prevented school closures, and several counties are experiencing fiscal strain. In response, the West Virginia Department of Education recently released a $410 million plan intended to address shortcomings in the formula.
State officials seek a pause
State school officials have agreed to a motion that would delay the case until after the next legislative session, allowing lawmakers additional time to consider reforms without the pressure of ongoing litigation.
Implications for West Virginia education policy
If the court grants the dismissal, the lawsuit’s claims that the formula violates constitutional obligations would be set aside, leaving the current funding structure in place pending any legislative changes. Supporters of the motion argue that the proper avenue for reform is through the legislature, not the courts, and that protecting legislative immunity preserves the separation of powers.
Community response
Local parents and education advocates have expressed concern that the formula does not adequately fund schools, especially in rural areas where enrollment declines have led to school closures. While the lawsuit’s dismissal would halt the current legal challenge, many stakeholders continue to call for a comprehensive review of how state aid is allocated.
The case underscores the ongoing debate in West Virginia over how best to fund public education while respecting constitutional mandates and legislative authority.
Original reporting: WCHS Eyewitness News Charleston (local) — read the source article.