FARGO, N.D. – The City of Fargo, together with Detective Lucas Heck, formally requested that a federal judge dismiss with prejudice a $10 million civil‑rights lawsuit filed by Tennessee resident Angela Lipps. The suit alleges that the city and its police department violated Lipps’ Fourth‑Amendment rights to be free from unlawful search and seizure, as well as her Fourteenth‑Amendment right to due process.
Background of the case
Lipps, a grandmother from Tennessee, was arrested on July 14, 2025, after investigators used artificial‑intelligence technology and facial‑recognition software to identify her as a possible suspect in multiple bank fraud investigations taking place in West Fargo and Fargo that spring. The AI system erroneously matched Lipps’ image to surveillance footage, leading to her detention and six months of incarceration.
During her detention, Lipps maintained that she was in Tennessee, a claim supported by bank and cellphone records presented by her attorneys. Those records show that her financial activity and mobile‑phone location were consistent with being in Tennessee at the time the alleged fraud occurred in North Dakota. The criminal charges against her were later dismissed.
City’s response and legal arguments
In a filing submitted Monday, Nov. 16, the city denied any constitutional violations and argued that its police officers acted in good faith based on the technology available at the time. The city contends that the AI‑driven identification was a reasonable investigative tool and that the subsequent arrest was conducted in accordance with established procedures.
Detective Heck, named as a defendant, is accused of two counts: violating Lipps’ Fourth‑Amendment rights and infringing her due‑process protections. The city itself faces a single count alleging failure to establish clear policies and procedures to prevent wrongful detentions.
Potential impact
If the judge grants the city’s request, the lawsuit would be dismissed with prejudice, meaning Lipps could not refile the same claim. The city’s legal team emphasizes that a dismissal would reaffirm the legitimacy of using advanced technology in criminal investigations, provided agencies maintain transparency and accountability.
Critics of the city’s stance point to the growing concerns about AI‑driven facial‑recognition systems and their potential for error, especially when they affect individuals’ liberty. However, the city maintains that the technology was employed responsibly and that the wrongful‑detention claim lacks sufficient legal grounding.
Next steps
The case will be heard by a federal judge, who will determine whether the city’s arguments merit dismissal or whether Lipps’ constitutional claims merit further litigation. The outcome could influence how law‑enforcement agencies across North Dakota and beyond balance the use of emerging technologies with the protection of civil liberties.
For now, the City of Fargo continues to assert that its police department acted within the bounds of the law and that the lawsuit does not reflect a systemic failure but rather an isolated incident.
Original reporting: InForum (Fargo section) — read the source article.