Scottsdale residents may soon see the iconic Pink Pony Steak House return to life on the corner of Scottsdale Road and First Street. The property at 3831 N. Scottsdale Road, a designated historic landmark, has sat empty for more than a decade after an unsuccessful revival attempt about 15 years ago.
Background on the Pink Pony
Constructed in 1954 as a Sprouse‑Reitz variety store, the building was converted in 1970 to house the Pink Pony Steak House after the restaurant moved from its original downtown location. Under owner Charlie Briley, the venue became a beloved gathering place for spring‑training baseball teams. Legends such as Ty Cobb, Ted Williams, Rogers Hornsby, Jimmie Foxx, Joe DiMaggio and Billy Martin were known to frequent the restaurant, which featured a wall of signed memorabilia and caricature drawings of players and coaches.
Plan to Re‑imagine the Site
In a letter dated November 5, the Scottsdale law firm Withey Morris Baugh announced that an internationally recognized food purveyor has purchased the property. The new owner has engaged architect Wendell Burnette to redesign the site as a collection of distinct dining concepts. Rather than a single large restaurant, the proposal calls for three high‑end eateries and a fourth venue that will honor the Pink Pony’s baseball heritage.
Historic Designation Issue
The redevelopment will require Scottsdale City Council approval to remove the building’s historic‑property designation. The law firm argues that the designation is no longer appropriate because the structure served as the Pink Pony’s second location and has undergone substantial alterations and deterioration over the years.
Community Involvement
Withey Morris Baugh is hosting an open house on Monday, November 16, at 5 p.m. at the site to discuss the project with neighboring businesses and interested residents. The meeting offers an opportunity for the community to learn about the proposed restaurant concepts, the preservation of the building’s baseball‑themed elements, and the anticipated economic impact on Old Town Scottsdale.
Potential Benefits
If approved, the development could bring new jobs, increase foot traffic along one of Scottsdale’s most prominent corridors, and restore a piece of local history that many longtime residents remember fondly. The inclusion of a tribute restaurant aims to preserve the Pink Pony’s legacy while providing modern dining experiences.
Next Steps
The City Council is expected to consider the request at an upcoming meeting. Stakeholders are encouraged to attend the open house or submit comments through the city’s planning portal before the council vote.
Original reporting: Scottsdale Progress — read the source article.