Cabell County, W.Va. – The West Virginia Parole Board denied parole Thursday for Cherelythia “Bunny” Holmes, a prisoner serving a life sentence for accessory to murder before the fact in the 2022 killing of Wendy Morgan. Holmes, who has long been a suspect in the 2004 prom‑night quadruple homicide of four teenagers, will not be eligible for parole again until November 1, 2027.
Background on the conviction
Holmes was convicted in 2022 after a jury found she had aided the planning and execution of Morgan’s murder. The conviction carries a mandatory life sentence without the possibility of early release, though the parole system allows a review after a set period.
Previous parole mishap
In 2025 Holmes was briefly slated for release due to a clerical error involving court orders and the official start date of her sentence. The mistake was quickly corrected, and her parole was denied at that time as well.
Ongoing investigation into the prom‑night killings
Although Holmes has never been charged in the 2005 murders of four teenagers during a high‑school prom, investigators continue to view her as a person of interest. The case remains open, and law‑enforcement officials say they will pursue any new evidence that may arise.
Parole board’s rationale
During the hearing, board members cited the seriousness of Holmes’ involvement in Morgan’s death and the unresolved questions surrounding the prom‑night murders. They emphasized the need to protect public safety and uphold the victims’ families’ rights.
Impact on the community
Local residents and victim‑advocacy groups expressed relief that the board acted decisively. “Justice for Wendy Morgan and the families of the prom victims is paramount,” said a spokesperson for a Huntington victim‑support organization. The decision underscores the community’s demand for accountability in violent crimes.
Future eligibility
Holmes will remain incarcerated until at least November 2027, when she may again petition the board for parole. Until then, she will continue to serve her sentence at the West Virginia State Penitentiary.
Original reporting: WCHS Eyewitness News Charleston (local) — read the source article.
