Federal immigration officials are on the hunt for Alonzo Reyes‑Garcia, a 38‑year‑old Mexican national with multiple violent convictions, after he was released from a New York City jail despite an ICE detainer. The case has ignited a sharp clash between the Department of Homeland Security and New York city leaders.
Background on the fugitive
Reyes‑Garcia, who also goes by the street name “Alberto Tellez,” has a documented history that includes third‑degree robbery, reckless assault causing injury, illegal weapons possession, contempt of court, and harassment of a family member. Federal records show an immigration judge ordered his removal from the United States in the fall of 2006, but he later re‑entered the country without authorization.
Release that sparked the dispute
According to ICE, a formal hold request was filed on Oct. 30 to keep Reyes‑Garcia in custody while his immigration case was processed. City jail officials, however, opened the cell and allowed him to leave, prompting ICE to label the action a breach of public‑safety protocol.
Trump administration’s response
Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin issued a forceful statement, accusing New York’s sanctuary officials of putting political considerations above the safety of American citizens. “Sanctuary politicians in New York refused to honor ICE’s detainer and released this illegal alien back onto the streets, despite his criminal convictions for robbery, assault, and other violent crimes,” Mullin said. He added that the Trump administration will continue to prioritize the removal of illegal aliens to keep communities safe.
Legal context of sanctuary policies
New York’s sanctuary law, which took effect in August, limits local law‑enforcement cooperation with federal immigration authorities. The policy is intended to foster trust between immigrant communities and local police, but critics argue it hampers the ability of federal agencies to detain individuals with criminal histories who are also illegal aliens.
Public safety appeal
Federal investigators have asked the public to help locate Reyes‑Garcia, providing a national tip line (866‑347‑2423). They stress that apprehending the fugitive is essential to prevent further violent incidents.
Local reaction
New York city officials have defended the release, citing the city’s legal obligations under the sanctuary statute. They argue that the policy does not prevent the removal of individuals who pose a clear threat, but rather requires due process and coordination with federal partners.
What’s at stake
The disagreement highlights the broader national debate over sanctuary laws, immigration enforcement, and public‑safety priorities. Supporters of the Trump administration view strict enforcement as a cornerstone of protecting American families, while sanctuary advocates emphasize community trust and constitutional protections for all residents.
How you can help
If you see Reyes‑Garcia, please call the tip line. Authorities stress that any information, no matter how small, could be vital to ensuring safety in New York and beyond.
Original reporting: Tampa Free Press — read the source article.
