Dallas residents saw a historic shift at Highland Park Methodist Church when members voted on October 25 and 26 to leave the United Methodist Church (UMC). The congregational vote, reported online at 5 p.m. Monday, recorded 4,775 ballots cast, with 90.35% supporting disaffiliation, according to Baptist News.
The vote represents about one‑third of the church’s “professing members,” according to the same source. Following the result, the Church Council announced that worship will resume on Sunday under the new name Highland Park Methodist Church, emphasizing continuity of its theological mission while asserting greater autonomy over clergy selection and property management.
Church leaders highlighted that the decision aligns with the congregation’s desire to protect its historic autonomy, maintain control over clergy appointments, and preserve its 110‑year legacy. The council stated, “Our Methodist identity is grounded in our faith, our Wesleyan theological tradition and the ministry to which God has called us,” and affirmed that these core elements will not change.
However, the departure is contested by denominational officials. Bishop Ruben Saenz of the Horizon Texas Conference, who learned that Highland Park had amended its governing documents three years earlier, filed a lawsuit in Dallas County court, arguing that the vote violates the UMC’s Book of Discipline and the denomination’s “trust clause,” which holds church property in trust for the UMC.
In response, the Horizon Texas Conference issued a statement saying, “While individuals are free to make their own decisions about their religious affiliation, a congregational vote does not, by itself, sever a local church’s relationship with The United Methodist Church.” The conference reiterated its request that Highland Park restore its governing documents to align with United Methodist governance.
Despite the legal dispute, the church council indicated that operational steps to complete the separation will be pursued, targeting December 1, 2026, for finalization. The council thanked members for their participation and prayerful consideration, noting the diversity of perspectives within the congregation.
What’s next: The lawsuit filed by Bishop Saenz will proceed in Dallas County court, and both parties are expected to present arguments regarding property ownership and governance authority. Highland Park Methodist Church plans to continue worship services under its new name while working toward the December 2026 deadline for completing the separation process.
Sources: baptistnews.com
