The recent crash of two U.S. Navy EA-18 Growlers during the Gunfighter Skies Air Show at Mountain Home Air Force Base in Idaho has sparked discussions about the risks involved in military air shows. These two jets, valued at $136 million, collided mid-air, leading to the successful ejection of all four crew members, with only one requiring hospital treatment for non-life-threatening injuries.
Military Demonstrations and Their Purpose
The Navy’s Growler Airshow Team, part of Electronic Attack Squadron 129 from Whidbey Island, Washington, was involved in the incident. The Growler, an electronic warfare aircraft based on the F/A-18 fighter jet platform, is no longer in production, making replacement costs significantly higher. Operating these jets costs approximately $20,000 per hour.
Despite the financial and safety risks, military air shows serve a purpose beyond entertainment. John Venable, a senior resident fellow at the Mitchell Institute for Aerospace Studies and former U.S. Air Force fighter pilot, explains that these demonstrations aim to foster community connections and appreciation for military precision and professionalism. The Navy’s Blue Angels and the Air Force’s Thunderbirds are the most renowned teams, performing at numerous events annually.
Cost-Benefit Analysis
A 2012 cost-benefit analysis by Navy officers revealed that the Blue Angels’ annual budget of approximately $98.6 million yielded less than $1 million in recruiting benefits, a negative return on investment. However, when considering the economic benefits to local communities, the negative return narrows to 41%.
Congress mandated a new cost-benefit study in 2024, but results have yet to be released. Despite past findings, the military continues to value these demonstrations for their public affairs and recruiting benefits, which are not easily quantifiable.
Community Impact and Risks
Air shows, whether featuring major teams or smaller units like the Growler team, involve inherent risks. Historical accidents include the 1982 “Diamond Crash” and other fatal incidents. Nevertheless, these events attract large audiences, providing a platform for the military to engage with the public and inspire future service members.
Venable emphasizes that air shows offer a unique opportunity for civilians to witness military capabilities firsthand, potentially sparking an interest in military service among attendees. The military’s commitment to these events underscores their perceived value in bridging the gap between the armed forces and the communities they serve.
Original reporting: 40/29 / KHBS (NW Arkansas) — read the source article.
