The parking lot off Lovers Lane was emptier than I expected for a Friday at 7 p.m., which made me nervous for about thirty seconds — then I walked in and every table was full. Nonna has been doing Italian in Dallas the right way since 2008, long before the city developed any real appetite for the kind of cooking that doesn’t feel the need to announce itself.
It’s in a converted Craftsman bungalow on Lovers Lane in the Preston Hollow corridor, and the inside feels exactly like that sounds: low ceilings, wood trim, rooms that open into other rooms in ways that don’t quite follow a grid. I sat in the back section where the light was warmer and the noise from the bar didn’t swamp conversation. My server had been there long enough to actually remember what sold out the week before, which is a detail you notice.
The menu changes with what’s available, but there are anchors. The tagliatelle with Bolognese is one of them, and it’s the reason people come back. The pasta is made in-house, with enough give to it that you know it wasn’t sitting in a walk-in for three days. The sauce is slow and deep and doesn’t have any of that bright tomato sweetness that shortcuts taste like. I ordered it with a glass of Barbera d’Asti that the server suggested without being pushed, and that combination alone made the drive worth it.
We also split the burrata to start — served simply, with a little olive oil and some grilled bread that had real char on it, not the pale toast that passes for grilled at half the places in town. The kitchen isn’t trying to impress you with technique; it’s trying to feed you something that makes sense. That restraint is harder to pull off than it looks.
Main courses hover in the $28–$42 range. The pasta dishes run $22–$28. It’s not cheap, but it’s not charging you for a room you’re not in, either. This is a neighborhood restaurant in the best sense of that phrase — people eat here on anniversaries and also on regular Tuesdays when they don’t want to cook.
One thing worth knowing: Nonna takes reservations, and you should use them. Walk-ins on a weekend are possible at the bar, which is a decent fallback if you forgot to plan ahead. The wine list leans Italian across the board and has options in the $45–$60 bottle range that won’t embarrass anyone. If you want something heavier, the Barolo is worth the splurge.
I finished with the panna cotta, which arrived the way it should — barely set, cool, with a small spoon of berry compote that cut the richness without overpowering it. I’ve had fancier desserts in this city. I’ve rarely had one that felt more considered.
Nonna doesn’t have a social media presence that makes you feel like you’re missing out. It doesn’t need one. The people who know about it keep going back, and that’s usually a better endorsement than anything else.