Nobody goes to Carmichael’s Bistro on a Tuesday. That’s exactly when you should.
The place sits on College Avenue, west of the downtown cluster, in a storefront that has housed at least three different restaurants over the past decade — which should tell you something about the real estate but nothing useful about Carmichael’s itself, because Carmichael’s has quietly outlasted most of its neighbors. It opened around 2015, and it’s still here, still doing dinner service, still making its own desserts, which is rarer than it ought to be in a mid-sized Wisconsin city.
I went on a Tuesday in late October because a friend suggested it and I had no strong objection. The dining room is small — maybe a dozen tables — with low lighting and a noise level that lets you have an actual conversation. The chairs are comfortable. I mention that because it’s the kind of thing you notice when you’re used to places that seem to have purchased the most punishing furniture available.
The menu is relatively compact, which I take as a good sign. A kitchen that tries to do fifty things usually does none of them well. Carmichael’s leans on seasonal midwestern ingredients without making a ceremony of it. There’s usually a fish, a steak, a pasta, a couple of thoughtful appetizers. The night I was there, the walleye was running as a special, pan-seared, with a lemon caper butter situation that was doing exactly what lemon caper butter is supposed to do. Entrées run roughly $22–$32.
We started with the charcuterie board, which came out generous and well-considered — not the kind where someone has clearly opened three packages and called it done. The house-made pâté was the highlight, though I’d have said the same about the pickled vegetables if the pâté hadn’t been there. We ordered a bottle of the Meiomi Pinot Noir, which is not an adventurous choice but was priced fairly and arrived at the right temperature, which is more than you can say for every restaurant in the Fox Valley.
Service was attentive without being the kind of attentive that makes you feel monitored. Our server knew the menu, had opinions when asked, and didn’t disappear for twenty-minute stretches. These are the basics, but the basics are frequently botched.
The crème brûlée came out at the end because I ordered it, obviously. It had a proper crust — the kind that cracks cleanly under a spoon rather than collapsing into soft pudding with a tan surface — and the custard underneath was set right, with a faint vanilla note that didn’t overdo it. It cost seven dollars. I’d pay it again.
Carmichael’s doesn’t get the same local buzz as some of the newer spots, partly because it doesn’t work the social media angle hard and partly because the food is good without being theatrical. It’s not trying to be the most photographed plate in town. It’s trying to be dinner, and it succeeds at that with enough consistency that I feel comfortable saying so in print.
Reservations are worth making on weekends. Tuesday, though, you can probably walk in. I’d recommend it.